Steel Mills
Judge Says No to US Steel Request to Shorten CCAA Protection for USSC
Written by Sandy Williams
May 1, 2016
In a surprise move on Friday, US Steel requested that the court shorten the CCAA protection period for US Steel Canada. US Steel Canada had petitioned the court to extend the CCAA period to July 28, 2016 but US Steel attorneys requested the Stay Period extend only to May 29.
Justice Herman Wilton-Siegel, who has been overseeing the Superior Court process, denied the US Steel request and ordered the Stay Period extended from April 29 to July 28, 2016.
Lawyers for USSC called the move an effort by US Steel to cripple the company, which is in the second phase of its sales process, and move it towards liquidation.
US Steel lawyer Michael Barrick claimed that prolonging the extension period would not “guarantee that any bid will produce more value than a liquidation.” Delaying a final restructuring of USSC was destroying its value, said the motion brought by US Steel.
US Steel, as 100 percent owner of USSC, would benefit from a quick sale or liquidation. The company just reported a net loss of $340 million for first quarter 2016.
Paul Streep, attorney for US Steel Canada, said that as long as the sales process was moving ahead there was a chance of a sale of the company as a “going concern.” There was nothing to be gained by imposing a quick deadline, said Streep, and would signal uncertainty to potential buyers about the company’s ability to survive.
Allen Mark, attorney for the provincial government said, “The only interest … would be the interest of U.S. Steel as a competitor to create the uncertainty that would result from a truncated stay.”
The Hamilton Spectator wrote, “Outside the court, union leaders said by asking for such a short extension of protection the American company wanted a scenario where bids for Stelco could not be properly evaluated. That would allow the parent company, as the largest creditor, to declare no acceptable bids were submitted and move for a liquidation order where it would claim the lion’s share of proceeds.”
Friday’s court session also resulted in a deferral by Wilton-Siegal on a decision to reveal the “secret deal” between US Steel and the government that ended a law suit against US Steel in 2011.
Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Steel Mills
U.S. Steel sues Algoma over iron pellet shipments
U.S. Steel is suing Algoma over the Canadian flat-rolled producer's rejection of iron pellet shipments, arguing it has breached its contract.
August US mill shipments slip but still higher than last year
The American Iron and Steel Institute reported a decline in the monthly shipments of US mills from July to August.
TransPod, Algoma, Supreme Steel linkup anchors Canadian steel in high-speed transit build
The three Canadian companies have announced a strategic partnership to support the development of an ultra-high-speed transit line from Edmonton to Calgary.
Metallus, USW agree to tentative four-year labor deal
Metallus and the United Steelworkers (USW) have agreed to a tentative four-year labor contract.
ArcelorMittal Dofasco resumes cokemaking after emergency maintenance
The Canadian steelmaker reported on Sept. 30 that “urgent maintenance” was needed in its coke plant off-gas systems. The work required coke oven gas from the No. 2 coke plant to be flared for most of that week.