SMU Data and Models
Service Centers Take Another Step Closer to “Capitulation”
Written by John Packard
December 10, 2018
Flat rolled steel service centers who responded to last week’s SMU flat rolled and plate steel market trends questionnaire are reporting in increasing numbers their service center as lowering spot prices to their customers. One month ago (early November) only 32 percent of the flat rolled distributors were reporting lower spot pricing to their customers. Now, we have seen that percentage grow to 72 percent. This is within a hair of what SMU has identified as the point of capitulation. In the past we have suggested that when 75 percent or more of the distributors advise their company as dropping steel prices, that was the inflection point or capitalization point. This is the point in time when so many service centers are dumping inventory at ever lower prices, thus devaluing inventory, that the process is putting the company at risk. It is the point of pain that can only be relieved by a change in pricing direction, which inevitably comes from the domestic steel mills raising prices.
What SMU does not know is how the markets will react when the U.S. government is so involved in setting pricing through tariffs, along with antidumping and countervailing duties.
With 93 percent of the manufacturing companies reporting their service center suppliers as lowering spot prices, in their minds the distributors are already at an inflection point. However, SMU does not rely solely on the comments of the manufacturing community alone; our capitulation indicator is based on the responses of the distributors themselves. It is the distributors who have to cry uncle (Uncle U.S. Steel, Uncle Nucor, etc.) and let the steel mills know they are willing and able to raise spot prices should the domestic mills go on the offensive.
SMU expects that as long as domestic mill spot prices, along with international prices, continue to drop, the flat rolled steel service centers will continue to follow and lower their spot pricing. Our readers should also note that capitulation may not be universal the moment our index hits 75 percent. Many times the distributors have to experience pain for some time before pushing for price increases by the domestic steel mills.
John Packard
Read more from John PackardLatest in SMU Data and Models
Apparent steel supply remains elevated in July
Apparent supply totaled 8.88 million short tons (st) in July, down 38,000 st from June and 6% higher than the same month last year
HRC vs. prime scrap spread narrows slightly
The price spread between prime scrap and hot-rolled coil (HRC) narrowed by a hair this month, according to SMU’s most recent pricing data.
SMU Scrap Survey: Current Sentiment rises as Future Sentiment falls
SMU’s current Scrap sentiment index increased this month while future sentiment declined, according to our latest ferrous scrap survey data.
SMU scrap market survey results now available
SMU’s September ferrous scrap market survey results are now available on our website to all premium members.
SMU Survey: Sentiment inches up from low levels
SMU’s Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices ticked higher this week, according to the latest data from our flat-rolled steel survey.