Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
Written by Michael Cowden
June 16, 2022
There have been some interesting developments in the plate market lately if you’ve been paying close attention.
Let’s start with Nucor’s price decrease on cut-to-length (CTL) plate. For starters, let’s be clear that it’s only CTL prices that were dropped. Prices for discrete plate are unchanged.
First, a little background. CTL plate refers to material that is produced as coil. That coil is then leveled and cut to length. Discrete plate, in contrast, is produced as plate – it doesn’t originate in coil form.
That distinction is worth emphasizing. But what’s more interesting are the dimensions of the CTL products on which Nucor chose to cut pricing.
Nucor dropped prices on material less than 72 inches wide and a ½ inch thick by $125 per ton ($6.25 per cwt). Prices for material 73-84 inches wide and up to or less than ½ inch thick were cut by $85 per ton ($4.25 per cwt).
Check out the snip below from Nucor’s updated price list:
As mentioned above, prices for discrete plate are unchanged. As for CTL plate, it really depends on the item.
Prices are unchanged for CTL material more than a half inch thick or more than 96 inches wide. But why would anyone pay $93 cwt ($1,860 per ton) for CTL plate 84-inch wide that is ¾ inch thick but only $84 per cwt ($1,680 per ton) for 84-inch wide ½ inch or less thick.
Our best guess is that this might be tacit acknowledgement by Nucor that there is competition on sizes up to 1/2-inch thick from SDI’s new mill in Sinton, Texas. Recall that Sinton, as any recent lead time sheet might tell you, makes what it calls “HR – Plate”. Basically, coil in much thicker sizes than traditional HRC.
Plate has held a very high premium over sheet products such as HRC lately. Could SDI be charging a HR base for what is typically considered a plate product – thereby offering a significantly lower price for an that item than what might be offered by plate mills?
I can’t say that with 100% certainty. But, again, I think it’s possible that Nucor’s CTL plate price reduction on the sizes mentioned above is the first acknowledgement by a major plate mill that adjustments because of competition from Sinton need to be made.
To be clear, I’m not saying that this is the beginning of a price war. Equity prices might be collapsing and sheet prices might be falling. But activity is not terrible depending on who you talk to. I’d interpret this as yet another sign that there is once again healthy competition for new business, particularly when it comes to plate.
I should also add that Nucor declined to comment for this article. Mills do not typically comment on pricing matters.
By Michael Cowden, Michael@SteelMarketUpdate.com

Michael Cowden
Read more from Michael CowdenLatest in Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
We’ve talked about tariffs ad nauseam for much of the year. And I’m afraid this topic isn’t going away anytime soon. There’s a feeling that the tariff “can” will just be kicked down the road again and again, and again.

Final Thoughts
Can technology help with pig iron and DRI/HBI tariffs?

Final Thoughts
Tariff-related noise aside, there is one basic factor keeping buyers on the sidelines. Despite recent declines, HR prices remain at historically high levels. And there is no obvious support to keep them there.

Final Thoughts
United Airlines raised eyebrows earlier this month when it provided two forecasts for 2025 – one assuming a relatively stable economy and another assuming a recession. The reason? Uncertainty around the impact of President Trump’s policy shocks on the broader economy. And it sometimes feels like we’re seeing a battle between those two narratives (stable vs recession) play out within in the pages of this newsletter.

Final Thoughts
Despite some scary headlines lately (especially about Trump potentially firing Fed Chair Jerome Powell) this is not October 2008 (financial crisis) or March 2020 (onset of the pandemic). But it sure seems like we’ve taken a relatively strong economy and poured a thick sauce of uncertainty over it.