Steel Mills

Cliffs swings to $242M loss in Q3, expects early 2025 demand rebound
Written by Ethan Bernard
November 4, 2024
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Third quarter ended Sept. 30 | 2024 | 2023 | % Change |
---|---|---|---|
Revenue | $4,569 | $5,605 | -18.5% |
Net earnings (loss) | $(242) | $264 | -191.7% |
Per diluted share | $(0.52) | $0.52 | -200% |
Nine months ended Sept. 30 | |||
Revenue | $14,860 | $16,884 | -12.0% |
Net earnings (loss) | $(307) | $554 | -155.4% |
Per diluted share | $(0.64) | $1.08 | -159.3% |
Cleveland-Cliffs swung to a steep loss in the third quarter. However, it touted the recent closing of its acquisition of Stelco in its quarterly earnings report released on Monday and said steel demand should bounce back early next year.
The Cleveland-based steelmaker posted a Q3’24 loss of $242 million vs. $264 million of net income attributable to Cliffs’ shareholders a year earlier. Revenue declined nearly 19% to $4.57 billion in the same comparison.
“In Q3, weaker demand and pricing drove tighter margins, and ultimately led us to temporarily idle our Cleveland #6 blast furnace,” Cliffs’ Chairman, President, and CEO Lourenco Goncalves said in a statement on Monday.
SMU reported in September that the C-6 blast furnace at Cliffs’ Cleveland Works in Ohio would be placed on hot idle in October. (See here for update.)
Goncalves noted that Cliffs achieved its lowest unit cost since 2021. However, “that was not enough to offset the negative impact of two of our top four automotive clients who continue to underperform their own expectations.”
“Due to our high exposure to the automotive sector, Cliffs was more affected than our competitors,” he added.
The company shipped 3.8 million short tons (st) of steel in Q3, down 7.3% from 4.1 million st in the year-ago quarter. Q3 shipments comprised 36% hot rolled, 28% coated, 17% cold rolled, 4% plate, 4% stainless and electrical, and 11% other, including slabs and rail.
Stelco acquisition
On Friday, Nov. 1, Cliffs closed on its acquisition of Stelco Holdings. The $2.5-billion deal to buy the Hamilton, Ontario-based steelmaker was first announced in July.
“We are thrilled to have closed on the acquisition of Stelco last week. Stelco’s portfolio of business is very different from ours, with virtually no exposure to the automotive sector,” Goncalves commented.
He added, “Stelco’s low-cost, efficient assets will make us more resilient in times of underperformance from the automotive clients.”
Cliffs said its Q3’24 results do not include Stelco’s Q3 adjusted EBITDA of US$64 million and adjusted EBITDA margin of 13%.
Capex outlook for 2024-25
Cliffs has lowered its full-year 2024 expected capital expenditures range to $600 million to $650 million vs. previous expectations of $650 million to $700 million.
For 2025, Cliffs anticipates standalone capex (excluding Stelco) to be ~$600 million.
“For 2025, we’ve set a much lower capital budget, even after including the strategic projects that are expected to boost annual EBITDA by over $600 million once completed,” Goncalves said.
He commented that lower coal costs will bring a $70-million benefit next year.
Looking to demand, Goncalves said Cliffs expects steel demand to rebound in early 2025, “supported by a number of economic and political factors.”
“With Stelco’s assets and our cost reductions, we’re well-positioned to capitalize on this upswing and will be able to reduce acquisition debt quickly with healthy free cash flow,” he concluded.

Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Steel Mills

Nucor reports improved earnings, sales, and operating rates
Nucor reported a sharp sequential rebound in the second quarter, buoyed by improved pricing and strong shipments. But the steelmaker is bracing for a modest slowdown in the months ahead.

Cliffs confirms Cleveland furnace restart, Dearborn furnace idling
Cleveland-Cliffs is idling blast furnace, BOF shop, and continuous caster functions at its Dearborn plant, but downstream operations will remain unaffected, the company confirmed. Cliffs said its pickling line tandeom cold mill (PLTCM) and its extra wide automotive-grade galvanizing line for exposed parts will continue operations at the Dearborn, Michigan-based facility.

Nucor spot HR list price unchanged at $900/ton
Nucor maintained its weekly list price for hot-rolled (HR) coil flat this week, following a price cut the previous week.

Despite trade chaos, Barry Schneider upbeat on SDI, steel
With 30 years of experience at Steel Dynamics, Barry Schneider reflects on the company and the state of the steel industry.

Algoma Steel seeks CAD$500M in operational support
Algoma Steel applied to Canada’s federal Large Enterprise Tariff Loan (LETL) program for $500 million to support its long-term operations.