Steel Mills

SMU Survey: Steel Mill Consolidation
Written by Brett Linton
September 18, 2014
Steel Market Update (SMU) conducted our mid-September flat rolled steel market analysis this week. We invited slightly more than 600 companies to participate in the latest survey which analyzes various trends which affect the flat rolled steel market. One set of questions had to do with the consolidation of the steel mills as SDI and AK Steel absorbed the former Severstal NA mills this week and Nucor has announced the purchase of Gallatin Steel.
First, we wanted to know how consolidation would affect the business relationships companies have with their suppliers. Would consolidation make negotiations more or less difficult or would there be no impact what-so-ever.
As you can see by our graphic the vast majority, 68 percent, of those responding to our questions believe consolidation will not impact their ability to negotiate with their suppliers. Twenty-six percent believe consolidation will make negotiations more difficult and 6 percent thought negotiations would become easier.
We believe this almost universal acceptance of change, with almost three-quarters of the respondents believing change to be good or have no affect on their business, is one of the reasons why our SMU Steel Buyers Sentiment Index rose by 11 points this week.
We had a number of comments left behind regarding this question. Here are some examples:
“I would certainly expect to see more discipline in the market relative to pricing.” Manufacturing Company
“The more limited the options the more power the producers have.” Service Center
“The supply base of specialty products (high carbon and alloy) is now much more constricted.” Service Center.
“There is still plenty of competition for all flat rolled products and while consolidation is certainly not a negative the impact will be minimal.” Service Center
“If the mills maintain (or increase) some of the pricing discipline that they have shown recently, steel pricing may not be subject to the major swings that have existed in past years. The opportunity for this to occur is significant.” Service Center
“We’re not big enough players to effect any changes, so we are at the mercy of reduced competition.” Service Center
“Less suppliers is never good for the customer.” Manufacturing Company
“I can’t believe our Justice department keeps turning a blind eye to this consolidation and collusion within the industry.” Manufacturing Company
Next we asked manufacturing companies and service centers to comment on whether consolidation would cause their company to consider buying more foreign steel. The results were consistent between the two market segments with 57 percent of the manufacturing companies and 53 percent of the service centers responding that they would consider buying more foreign steel because of consolidation of the industry.
In the responses, a number of our respondents pointed out that it was not consolidation that would cause them to buy more foreign steel, rather it is the spread between the domestic prices and those available from the rest of the world.
Aside from this week’s survey we also spoke with a number of buyers who were interested in foreign steel. It seems buyers have broken into two camps: 1) those who no longer believe the threat of dumping suits on cold rolled or coated products and are buying from those countries suggested as potential targets (China, India, Taiwan) or 2) those companies who do believe the threat of suits and are searching for trading companies who represent South American or European steel mills who would have interest in shipping to the United States. It will be interesting to see what happens in the coming months with each of these groups.

Brett Linton
Read more from Brett LintonLatest in Steel Mills

AHMSA opens doors to potential buyers as $1.3B asset auction nears
AHMSA is opening its doors to potential buyers to tour its steel plant and mining operations in northern Mexico in preparation for the next stage of its bankruptcy process: the auction of its assets.

USW seeks clarity on USS plans for Granite City Works
The United Steelworkers union has asked U.S. Steel to elaborate on its Granite City Works plans following reports that the steelmaker is ending processing at the facility.

Nucor maintains plate prices, opens October order book
Nucor aims to keep plate prices flat for a seventh straight month with the opening of its October order book.

ArcelorMittal Mexico to import from sister mills as it works to resume DRI production
ArcelorMittal has partially restarted operations at its direct reduction plant in Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan. An explosion on Aug. 18 rocked the massive steelworks on Mexico’s Pacific coast, impacting production of direct-reduced iron (DRI).

Fall maintenance outages are coming in hot
Labor Day has passed, the sun is starting to set a little earlier each day, and cooler weather has begun to find its way down to many of us across North America. And you know what that means for the steel industry… Fall maintenance outages!