Trade Cases

MSCI Addresses Circumvention and Overcapacity in Section 232 Testimony
Written by Sandy Williams
June 1, 2017
The Metals Service Center Institute (MSCI) submitted written testimony to the Commerce Department in support of the Section 232 Investigation of Steel Imports on National Security.
MSCI president and CEO M. Robert Weidner argued that unfair trading practices and global overcapacity, particularly by China, have harmed the U.S. steel market.
“MSCI believes the health of the U.S. domestic steel industry is critical to the entire U.S. manufacturing sector and the broader U.S. economy,” Weidner said. “Problems posed by foreign government-sponsored capacity expansion demand response from the U.S. government.”
In his statement, Weidman wrote:
“In particular, China has, through various anti-competitive mechanisms such as massive state sponsored subsidies, substantially increased its domestic steel industry in the last several years. This massive production growth comes during a time of stagnant—and negative—growth in its own steel consumption, when free market forces would dictate industry restructuring and consolidation. With investment in new capacity continuing to grow, and with growth in steel consumption expected to remain moderate, worldwide excess capacity in the steel sector will, if left unaddressed, continue to increase. “
“The causes of global excess capacity must be addressed to ensure a thriving North American industrial metals manufacturing industry, a healthy American economy and a secure nation,” said Weidner. “If the U.S. does not address this problem now, it will only get worse.”
Declining service center shipments are a clear indicator of injury from unfair trade practices, said Weidner. Carbon steel shipments in 2016 were down 34 percent from peak years before the 2008 recession.
Crude steel production dropped 10 percent in 2015 to 78.9 million tonnes and capacity utilization averaged just 70.1 percent, as noted by the ITA, said Wiedner. Production cutbacks contributed to loss of steel jobs as well as jobs in the fabricated metals industry downstream.
Job losses and plant closures are not due to U.S. inability to produce steel and products competitively, said Weidner, but are a result of unfairly subsidized foreign imports.
“The U.S. government, in an attempt to correct these actions, has rightfully imposed tariffs on various metals from countries that it has deemed to be unfairly subsidizing its metal exports to the United States,” Weidner explained. “However, there is growing evidence, that in an attempt to circumvent those rightfully imposed duties, the Chinese and others are simply processing that same steel into steel parts. These countries cannot be allowed to continue to circumvent U.S. rules and regulations.”
To address this circumvention, MSCI advised federal officials to provide relief for producers up and down the supply chain and to consider consequences of any new trade policy, including: the economic impact of global overcapacity on the entire domestic metals supply chain; transition times and implementation rules to any new policy; availability of domestic metals to meet U.S. national security needs, as well as general industrial and consumer demand; and trade flows under current free trade agreements, including NAFTA, where the written testimony requested the exclusion of Canada and Mexico from trade penalties resulting from the 232 investigation on steel.
“The inescapable conclusion is that something more than classic, free market forces are at work in the global steel market, in ways that have harmed U.S. producers and manufacturers, the steel service center industry and U.S. workers,” said Weidner.
The full comments by MSCI can be accessed here.

Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Trade Cases

US and Canada expect positive outcomes from tariff negotiations
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump told reporters at the White House on Tuesday that they’ll be formulating a trade deal that works for both nations.

Leibowitz: When the shutdown should end
There is no doubt that the current government shutdown reflects the vast divisions between the extremes of American politics, society, and even geography. Almost all Americans agree that government is necessary, but voters disagree...

Price: The U.S. Steel shutdown that wasn’t and a call to stop ‘valuation cheating’
How can the U.S. government block U.S. Steel’s Granite City rolling mill closure without harming other American steelmakers? Reducing imports should be the first step. Foreign producers continue to aggressively target the U.S. market, especially now as they find themselves displaced by Chinese exports.

US steel industry applauds ITC final determination in coated trade case
Domestic mills praised the US International Trade Commission’s (ITC's) final determination that imports of corrosion-resistant (CORE) steel from 10 countries pose a threat to them.

ITC’s final ruling: Dumped, subsidized CORE imports are harming domestic market
The US International Trade Commission (ITC) finds that corrosion resistant steel (CORE) imports from 10 countries have caused material damage to domestic product producers, according to the ITC’s statement.