Trade Cases
How Do U.S. Steel Duties Compare to Other Nations?
Written by Tim Triplett
March 11, 2018
President Trump made headlines this week when he slapped a 25 percent tariff on steel imports from all nations except Canada and Mexico. His rationale is that the U.S. should treat other countries the way they treat us. Steel Market Update has heard many incorrect statements about how the rest of the industrialized world treats U.S. exports. Closer examination shows that the administration’s claims of inequity are not necessarily true, at least when it comes to steel.
The United States exports steel products to Canada, Mexico and other countries, as well as scrap, iron ore and other inputs used to make steel, in most cases paying no duty at all, said Washington trade attorney Lewis Leibowitz.
He points to the Uruguay Round of trade negotiations in the early 1990s in which the industrialized nations agreed to a “zero for zero” policy, eliminating tariffs on steel, as well as fish, beer, pharmaceuticals, paper, wood, non-ferrous metals, electronics and construction equipment. In the United States, the reductions were phased in over a five-year period, hitting zero by 1999. The same was true for the EU, Japan and other countries.
“So, developed-world tariffs on steel are essentially zero,” said Leibowitz. “The only duties now are AD/CVD duties, some safeguard duties (e.g., India) and now the 25 percent duties courtesy of President Trump.”
Other nations have higher duties than the U.S. on other products. For example, the EU has higher duties on cars. But not on steel products, he added.
A March 8 Washington Post report concludes that the U.S. has one of the most open markets for trade, but it disputes the Trump administration’s claim that the U.S. has the lowest tariffs and the lowest non-tariff barriers in the world.
SMU Publisher John Packard participated in a steel panel at the FMA annual meeting in Scottsdale this past week. During that panel, comments were made advising the attendees that Europe and other industrialized nations place duties on U.S. steel products. There are countries (like China) that do have duties, but as Leibowitz explained, most industrial nations do not collect duties on steel.
Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in Trade Cases
Price on Trade: IEEPA tariffs head to the Supreme Court, DOJ ramps up trade enforcement
International trade law and policy remain a hot topic in Washington and beyond this week. We are paying special attention to the ongoing litigation of the president’s tariff policies and the administration’s efforts to heighten trade enforcement.
Mexico considers stiff tariffs for steel, autos, and other imports
Mexico is considering imposing steep tariffs on imports of steel, automobiles, and over 1,400 other products. Its target? Countries with which it does not have free trade agreements, mainly China, India, Thailand, and other South Asian nations.
Leibowitz: With ‘reciprocal’ tariffs struck down again in court, what happens next?
President Trump’s “reciprocal” tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Policy Act (IEEPA) were struck down again, this time on Aug. 29 by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC). The legal and policy mess continues, with the next stop being the US Supreme Court.
Market unfazed by US circuit court’s IEEPA decision
Repealing any reciprocal tariffs placed by President Donald Trump on US imports of direct reduced iron (DRI), iron ore, hot-briquetted iron (HBI), and pig iron would have only a nominal impact on the US steel market, market participants said.
ITC votes to keep HR duties after sunset review
The US government determined this week that hot-rolled steel imports from a handful of countries continue to threaten the domestic steel industry.