Trade Cases

BlueScope loses court challenge of HR sunset review
Written by Laura Miller
August 10, 2024
The Court of International Trade (CIT) has ruled against BlueScope Steel and its affiliates’ challenge of a sunset review of the antidumping duties on hot-rolled (HR) steel flat imports.
Background
In the 2021-22 sunset review of the duties, the International Trade Commission (ITC) cumulatively assessed hot-rolled steel imports from Australia alongside the same imports from other countries in the review – Japan, South Korea, Netherlands, Russia, Turkey, and the United Kingdom. Brazil was the only country in the review that didn’t have its shipments cumulated with the others.
The sunset review resulted in the removal of the antidumping duty (AD) order on Brazilian HR but the continuation of duties on HR from the other seven countries.
Sunset challenge
On Jan. 1, 2023, BlueScope Steel and its US affiliates, BlueScope Steel Americas and North Star BlueScope, challenged the ITC’s decision to cumulate the imports in the CIT. Specifically, they disputed the “finding that subject imports from Australia would likely compete under similar conditions of competition to those faced by imports from other subject countries,” according to a court document.
The ITC found that BlueScope, Australia’s only producer, has an incentive and a demonstrated interest in competing for sales in the US market.
The CIT said the ITC is allowed to cumulatively assess imports if they are likely to compete with each other and domestically produced product and if they are likely to negatively impact the domestic industry.
But BlueScope argued that its sales to its US affiliate Steelscape shouldn’t be considered sales in the US merchant market. Therefore, they would not be in competition with US-produced product.
However, considering BlueScope’s production capacity, the ITC said its sales wouldn’t be limited to Steelscape alone. Since other US steel producers can compete in the Western US, where Steelscape is located, the ITC determined that BlueScope’s sales would be in direct competition with domestic producers.
CIT decision
Despite BlueScope’s arguments, the CIT upheld the ITC’s decision to cumulate Australia’s HR exports with the other countries, saying it was lawful and supported by evidence.
The CIT concluded that the ITC “reasonably determined that BlueScope would maintain an incentive to export hot-rolled steel to the US market upon revocation of the antidumping duty order.”
As such, Judge Gary S. Katzmann signed the CIT opinion sustaining the ITC’s sunset review determination.
Note that domestic producers Cleveland-Cliffs, Steel Dynamics Inc., SSAB, Nucor, and U.S. Steel participated as defendant-intervenors in the case.
BlueScope could not be reached for comment by the time of this story’s publication.
Laura Miller
Read more from Laura MillerLatest in Trade Cases
Leibowitz: Renewed trade war with China over rare earths
On Oct.10, President Trump announced major increases in tariffs on Chinese goods. The trigger was a new regime of export controls on rare earth metals and products using those elements, including magnets, capital equipment, and catalysts for catalytic converters in cars and trucks.
Industry piles on new Section 232 steel derivative inclusion requests
The Department of Commerce received 97 submissions from producers, manufacturers, and groups seeking Section 232 tariff coverage for steel and aluminum derivative products.
Price on Trade: New EU steel tariffs don’t mean the US should weaken its stance
Any steel imports into the EU that exceed the new, lower quota level would be subject to a 50% tariff, which represents a major increase from the EU’s current 25% out-of-quota tariff. This move would largely align the EU’s steel tariff rate with Canada and the United States.
Global steel forum sets 2026 framework deadline as US ups pressure on excess capacity
Global steelmakers sounded the alarm Friday over the deepening excess steelmaking capacity crisis. Ministers at the Global Forum on Steel Excess Capacity (GFSEC) in Gqeberha, South Africa, pledged to...
CRU: China’s indirect steel exports find new destination markets
The boom in China’s direct steel exports has not stopped this year, even with a rise in protectionist measures globally. The increase is driven by...
