Features

SMU Scrap Survey: Current Sentiment rises as Future Sentiment falls
Written by Ethan Bernard & Stephen Miller
September 8, 2025
SMU’s Current Sentiment Index for scrap increased this month while our Future Sentiment Index declined, according to the latest data from our ferrous scrap survey.
This comes as market sources report obsolescent grades traded sideways in September. Busheling, meanwhile, was seen down $20 per gross ton (gt).
Current Sentiment Index
SMU’s Current Sentiment Index for scrap rose three points to +72 in September vs. +69 a month earlier. This is well within the 63-77 band we’ve seen it in since February.

Future Sentiment Index
SMU’s Future Sentiment Index for scrap dipped by two points to +81 compared with August. Even with the drop, future sentiment continues to track higher than current sentiment.

What’s the word on the street?
The word on the street is the market was a bit sloppy in September. There was dealer resistance to dropping prices on shredded and HMS. And flow on these grades has fallen off a bit.
But sellers did not resist a $20/gt decline in prime grades because much of the trade in prime is governed by formula pricing.
About SMU’s Scrap Sentiment
SMU’s Current and Future Scrap Sentiment Indices mirror the Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices in our flat-rolled steel survey. Our Scrap Sentiment Indices are both diffusion indices. Readings above 50 indicate a more bullish outlook, while readings below 50 indicate a more bearish one.
Sentiment is only one of the indicators we measure. Our scrap survey, like our steel survey, is available only to premium members. If you would like to upgrade from executive to premium, please contact SMU account executive Luis Corona at luis.corona@crugroup.com. If you’re interested in participating in our scrap survey, please reach out to david@steelmarketupdate.com.

Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan Bernard
Stephen Miller
Read more from Stephen MillerLatest in Features

Final Thoughts
We moved our pricing momentum indicators from “lower” to “neutral” for all sheet products this week. For those keeping score, we had been at “lower” for six weeks. And I know some of you think we should have been there for even longer.

AISI: Raw steel production ticks back up
Raw steel production has stayed historically strong over the past four months, holding near multi-year highs since June.

Metallus and United Steelworkers extend contract, negotiate new terms
Metallus and the United Steelworkers (USW) union extended their contract to Oct. 15 as talks continue on a new labor deal.

Final Thoughts: The long shadow of Ken Iverson
Renowned Nucor Chairman and CEO Ken Iverson would’ve turned 100 on Sept. 18 of this year.

Price: The U.S. Steel shutdown that wasn’t and a call to stop ‘valuation cheating’
How can the U.S. government block U.S. Steel’s Granite City rolling mill closure without harming other American steelmakers? Reducing imports should be the first step. Foreign producers continue to aggressively target the U.S. market, especially now as they find themselves displaced by Chinese exports.