Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by Brett Linton & Ethan Bernard
December 19, 2024
What would you do if you had a time machine? Would you lobby Ford to keep the F-150 made of steel? Would you become the most successful purchasing manager in steel history, with a keen knack for being one step ahead of price volatility? Or would you go forward, maybe hit up 2050 to see how all the fuss turned out with those carbon neutral targets?
Well, here at SMU, we can’t go forward. But we can look back. So as we wind down for the final two issues of 2024, we’re going to peer into the rearview of Decembers past: one year ago, five years ago, 10 years ago, and 100 years ago. Let’s take a look.
December 2023
Of course, the big news from December last year was Nippon Steel’s play for U.S. Steel. That was to the tune of a $14.9-billion offer. (You can find our original article here.)
One year later, and this one is still very much with us. The US Committee on Foreign Investment’s (CFIUS) national security review decision is expected any day now. So this could be one we close the book on in 2024. Or, we just might get thrown a curveball.
A takeaway for me is just how fast the received wisdom can change on a subject. The transaction went from being regarded as a nearly sure thing to high skepticism that it would be OK’d. Still, 2024 was quite a political year and it’s hard to imagine that didn’t affect the calculus of how the deal would pan out.
December 2019
Searching through SMU’s December 2019 archives, I found this timely Dec. 22, 2019, piece from trade attorney and current SMU columnist Lewis Leibowitz: “Leibowitz on Trade: House Votes to Approve USMCA.”
He speaks of the “protectionist” impulses in USMCA as compared to its predecessor, NAFTA.
With all the new talks of additional tariffs under Trump 2.0, and a review of the USMCA set for 2026, we’ll see what changes will come to the agreement. How will they affect the North American trading bloc?
The article’s conclusion stands out to me in particular, but perhaps in ways the author didn’t originally intend:
“I think we are in for an eventful 2020. I look forward to discussing the issues with you over the coming year.”
Leibowitz wrote that before most people had any familiarity with the Chinese city of Wuhan.
An eventful 2020, indeed!
Even further back…
And now for a real sense of history, I will turn over the reins to SMU Senior Analyst Brett Linton. He started with SMU way back in 2010, so history is a bit of his specialty.
December 2014
Ten years ago, steel prices were also gradually trickling lower. In the last week of December 2014, our hot-rolled coil average price dropped to a year-and-a-half low of $600 per short ton (st). Adjusted for inflation, that’s about $790/st – more expensive than the prices we are seeing today!
100 years ago!
Now, if we take a trip back a whole century, our friend Google says that hot-rolled steel prices were in the ballpark of $50/st in 1924. That’s the equivalent of paying about $890/st in today’s dollars.
2025?
With Jan. 1 just around the corner, this next year remains unwritten. Here at SMU, we’re hoping it’s a prosperous one and full of abundance for all of you!
We thank you for your continued interest in Steel Market Update!
Brett Linton
Read more from Brett Linton
Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
We surveyed many of you this week and asked what you wanted to see from the new Trump administration. Responses were varied but fell largely into three groups: tariffs and trade policy, the Nippon-U.S. Steel deal, and those who are concerned about too much government sway in steel. Some also expressed hope that President Trump would continue the infrastructure spending that began under former President Biden.
Final Thoughts
Sometimes new presidential administrations hit the ground running. No time for change like the present. And sometimes new administrations blast off on a SpaceX rocket bound for Mars. There’s a big universe, and we’ve got a lot of flags to plant. Such seems to be the case with the new Trump administration.
Final Thoughts
What’s been the impact of tariff threats on prices and demand? In short, not much – or at least that was the case when I was writing this column on Sunday afternoon. Spot activity for Canadian material, for example, has been put on hold over the last few weeks while the market waits to see what the new tariff landscape might look like.
Final Thoughts
Next Monday marks the start of the second Trump administration. The limbo we’ve been living in since Election Day in early November will finally come to an end. What better way to take a look at what’s coming up in Washington, D.C., than a conversation with Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA) President Philip K. Bell. He […]
Final Thoughts
It’s another week of big headlines and ho-hum pricing moves – which is to say the start of 2025 is looking a lot like the end of 2024. Scrap has settled up $20 per gross ton (gt). Steel prices, however, were a soft sideways this week. Chalk it up to uneven demand and abundant supply. And while we’re not aware of any major outages, some of you tell us that you’ve lost some shipping days here and there because of the recent cold snap.