• Skip to main content

    Analysis

    Leibowitz: US steel prices skyrocket above world prices. Which are right?

    Written by Lewis Leibowitz


    Editor’s note

    This is an opinion column. The views in this article are those of an experienced trade attorney on issues of relevance to the steel market. They do not necessarily reflect those of SMU. We welcome you to share your thoughts as well at smu@crugroup.com.

    Steel markets in the United States now feature supply shortages in many of the most important steel products, including not only hot- and cold-rolled sheet but galvanized sheet as well. Spot tons are well-nigh unavailable, and even contract tons are scarce.

    I’ve seen no evidence that mills are violating their contracts with their important customers, like automotive and construction. But the only way to tell that is when customers sue their suppliers for breach of contract.

    Based on the available statistics, the US market for these flat-rolled products is seriously constrained. The US economy is still the strongest in the world, and manufacturing output remains vigorous. But the available supply is tight.

    The numbers

    The reason is fairly obvious. US domestic supply has increased a bit. Meanwhile, imports fell significantly in January-August 2026 compared to the first eight months of last year. For hot-rolled sheet and strip, for example, domestic shipments increased about 9% in January-August 2026 vs. the same period a year ago. Meanwhile, total imports declined by 28.2%. Thus, the supply gap for hot-rolled sheet increased by about 19% in 2026. The supply numbers for cold-rolled sheet are even more stark: 2026 domestic shipment numbers increased by a mere 0.1%, while imports declined by 28.3%.

    Unfortunately for domestic steel buyers, some of the announced domestic capacity additions won’t be here for several years, and the market may change in the meantime.

    These figures are obviously subject to some debate. For example, domestic shipments of cold-rolled sheet might not be sold into the market but instead coated with zinc (galvanized) by the same mill that produced them. By the same token, increased hot-rolled shipments might be sold to rerollers that cold roll them.

    Nevertheless, the numbers are basically an apples-to-apples comparison from one year to the next. They illustrate a clear trend over the last year (January-August). Import penetration percentages require comparable domestic and import products that are identical (they are not) and the quantity of domestic shipments (they are sadly not public). But we can compare the ratio of imports to domestic shipments. Setting the 2025 ratio equal to 100, the 2026 ratios are:

    • Hot rolled sheet: -34.2
    • Cold rolled sheet: -28.4
    • Galvanized sheet: -48.3

    These are not import penetration figures, but the ratio of imports to domestic shipments. And they are not exactly apples to apples because of different product definitions. However, the trend, at least in flat-rolled sheet, is clear. Imports declined sharply in 2026 compared to shipments. And the increases in domestic shipments were much smaller in percentage terms than the declines in imports.

    The takeaway

    Several conclusions are possible from these admittedly fuzzy statistics.

    First, the information available in the market makes informed decision-making difficult. Domestic shipment information does not match the product definitions for imports. Moreover, contract shipments and prices are almost entirely unavailable, and contract tons are a major part of domestic steel shipments. US steel companies might like this fog. But it’s debatable whether the country is better off with such incomplete market information.

    Second, imports are a very important part of the domestic market. When tariffs cause massive declines in imports, and domestic shipments don’t fill the gap, price increases are an inescapable result. US prices now stand massively above prices in the rest of the world. By some estimates, hot-rolled sheet prices in the US are three times those in China and 1.5 times those in Europe. For most “steel derivative” products, a Section 232 tariff of 25% does not make up that difference. The result: imports, especially those of downstream products containing steel, are likely to increase. It may be that those downstream imports are increasing already. That would be a challenge to figure out, but it would be worth doing.

    Third, while my friends in the domestic industry might disagree, there is absolutely no evidence that current prices in the US are “right” and that global prices are “wrong.” Yet domestic industry advocates continually assert that US prices are a correct measure of supply, demand, and costs.

    While I agree that the global market is affected by overproduction, caused largely by government subsidies, the world is at least starting to address these problems (over the entirely unsurprising objections from China). All steel-producing countries are eager to have everyone else cut production and capacity—just not themselves.

    Forever tariffs

    This is a prescription for “forever tariffs” to go along with “forever wars.” China and the US would like these discussions to go on for a hundred years or so: China because it has spent handsomely to develop steel capacity no longer needed in its domestic market, and the US because the imposition of tariffs should last until the impossible happens—an international agreement to shutter excess capacity.

    A pending Section 301 investigation about systemic excess production will probably be finalized by the US Trade Representative’s office after the Nov. 3 midterm elections. It will probably find overcapacity in several industries, including steel and its downstream products. What does that mean for US steel buyers? Get ready for more tariffs!

    Lewis Leibowitz, SMU Contributor

    Lewis Leibowitz

    Read more from Lewis Leibowitz

    Latest in Analysis

    Contracts are done and dusted—what comes next?

    Editor's note: Due to a technical error, SMU sent last week’s edition of Final Thoughts earlier today. Please click on the headline above or the “Read more” button below to read this week’s Final Thoughts. You can also find the article here: https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/2026/11/20/final-thoughts-contracts-are-done-and-dusted-what-comes-next/ Contract negotiations, whether about labor or prices, have wrapped up—just in time for Thanksgiving. And I know some of you think the holidays can't come soon enough after a very hectic year for steel. U.S. Steel and the United Steelworkers (USW) union have tentatively agreed to terms of a new four-year labor deal. That news comes after Cleveland-Cliffs and the USW inked a tentative four-year labor deal earlier this month.

    North American auto output rebounds in October

    North American auto assemblies rebounded 6.5% from September to 1.369 million units in October, driven by improved personal and commercial vehicle production, according to GlobalData. After steady gains through Q2, automotive production has been inconsistent, continuing a seesaw pattern, evident again last month. Still, assemblies remain muted and well below pre-pandemic levels. Total production was nearly even with October 2025, down 0.5% from a year earlier. Still, last month’s production total was 6.3% above 2026’s monthly average of 1.287 million units.

    HARDI: Galvanized buyers see prices rising amid constrained supply

    Service centers and manufacturers on the Nov. 18 HARDI Sheet Metal and Air Handling Council call continued to report tight galvanized sheet supply, long lead times and rising costs. In a poll at the end of the call, all participants said they expect prices to increase over the next 30 days. Service center participants said incoming steel was selling quickly, leaving limited room to rebuild inventories or take on new customers. Several reported lead times of about 12 weeks or longer. One participant noted shipment delays were adding to the planning challenge.