Steel Products

Ethics and Your Business: Negotiation’s Golden Rule
Written by Tim Triplett
October 7, 2017
Negotiations in the steel business can often become contentious as both parties seek to win the best price and terms. Some experts say ethical negotiating is not only the right thing to do, it’s also more likely to achieve the desired outcome.
As academics Reitz, Wall & Love wrote, unethical bargaining can reap one-time benefits, but in the long run can damage relationships, sully reputations and close the door on future transactions.
Lies, deception, manipulation of information and puffery are common, but questionable, tactics in many negotiations.
To lie, to make a statement that is untrue about some material aspect of the transaction, is clearly unethical. But what about deception, an act or statement intended to mislead the other party about the negotiator’s intent? Or nondisclosure of important information that could benefit your opponent? Or exploiting information provided by your opponent by using it against them or sharing it with others?
While not outright lying, being deceptive and exploitative shows a lack of good faith and is likely to backfire on you, especially if you hope to do business with the other party in the future. Even puffery— exaggerating the value of some factor so that conceding it later yields a disproportionate return—is considered a questionable tactic by many ethicists.
Experienced negotiators may be thinking, so what’s left? Ethics experts say neither party to a negotiation is required to disclose personal information that could harm their case. For example, they do not have to disclose how much they are willing to pay, though they should not lie about it. They do not have to disclose the true value of a product to a buyer who is ignorant or misinformed. Let the buyer beware. And it is not wrong to maximize your payoff at your counterpart’s expense, as long as it is achieved in an ethical manner.
As the Golden Rule of negotiation goes, negotiators should pursue their own interests only as far as they would want opponents to pursue theirs.
Editor’s note: Have you ever faced an ethical dilemma in your business? How did you handle it, and what was the outcome? Share your experience with SMU’s readers by emailing Tim@SteelMarketUpdate.com. We promise to keep your identity confidential.

Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in Steel Products

US rig count slips, Canada ticks higher
ncreases through September, according to the latest Baker Hughes rig count data.

CRU: EC to toughen steel safeguards
The European Commission proposes cutting its steel import quota by almost half, with volumes exceeding the limit facing 50% duties. The region’s steel industry welcomes the move, while other steel-producing nations fear the consequences. CRU published an insight before this announcement, noting that more restrictive trade policy could significantly raise the cost of marginal supply […]

US and Canadian rig counts stabilize
US counts continue to hover just above historic lows, while Canadian figures remain comparatively healthy.

Plate market sources critique mill hikes amid current market conditions
Following spot market plate price increase notices issued by domestic mills this past week, participants are contemplating the rationale behind the increases and whether they will stick. Some sources anticipate that current market conditions will shift in November and believe the increases may set a new "pricing floor."

Oregon Steel Mills lifts plate prices by $60/ton
Oregon Steel Mills has joined other producers in announcing a price increase of at least $60 per short ton on steel plate.