Trade Cases
Coalition voices concern about potential duties on tin mill products
Written by Laura Miller
December 4, 2023
A coalition of manufacturers, retailers, and stakeholders stands opposed to the imposition of import duties on tin mill products.
Recall that the International Trade Commission (ITC) and the Department of Commerce’s International Trade Administration (ITA) are conducting a trade case investigating the alleged dumping and subsidization of tin mill products from a host of countries. The case was requested by Cleveland-Cliffs and the United Steelworkers (USW) union.
On Nov. 30, a group led by the Consumer Brands Association sent a letter to the two agencies voicing their concerns about how the potential tariffs would hurt US manufacturing and raise consumer prices.
Among the 28 signers of the letter were the Can Manufacturers Institute, the American Coatings Association, the Agriculture Transportation Coalition, and the National Foreign Trade Council.
“Domestic tin mill steel producers currently have the capacity to supply only approximately 50% of total US demand,” the letter said. Additionally, “Certain types and widths of steel required by US can manufacturers, including two-piece can steel, are not available in sufficient commercial quantities from domestic suppliers,” the group pointed out.
“Certain types of steel required within the can industry … currently are only sourced through imports,” the letter notes.
“…We believe there is substantial product differentiation and reason for subject imports apart from cost,” it added.
“It is evident that the proposed tariffs would result in serious injury to American consumers and manufacturers in the form of lost jobs and higher prices at the grocery store. We, the makers of America’s favorite household products, urge the ITC and the Department of Commerce to follow the facts and reject this dangerous proposal,” stated David Chavern, president and CEO of Consumer Brands.
In June, a bipartisan group of 36 members of Congress also expressed their concerns over the potential tariffs due to the downstream impact on manufacturers.
Preliminary ITA rulings
The ITA made its initial ruling in the antidumping portion of the case in August. It found that Canada, China, and Germany dumped the subject goods at margins of 5.29-122.52%. It also said the Netherlands, Taiwan, Turkey, and the UK did not dump the product.
In the countervailing duty part of the case, the ITA determined preliminary countervailable subsidy rates of 89.02-542.55% for China.

Laura Miller
Read more from Laura MillerLatest in Trade Cases

Price on Trade: IEEPA tariffs head to the Supreme Court, DOJ ramps up trade enforcement
International trade law and policy remain a hot topic in Washington and beyond this week. We are paying special attention to the ongoing litigation of the president’s tariff policies and the administration’s efforts to heighten trade enforcement.

Mexico considers stiff tariffs for steel, autos, and other imports
Mexico is considering imposing steep tariffs on imports of steel, automobiles, and over 1,400 other products. Its target? Countries with which it does not have free trade agreements, mainly China, India, Thailand, and other South Asian nations.

Leibowitz: With ‘reciprocal’ tariffs struck down again in court, what happens next?
President Trump’s “reciprocal” tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Policy Act (IEEPA) were struck down again, this time on Aug. 29 by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC). The legal and policy mess continues, with the next stop being the US Supreme Court.

Market unfazed by US circuit court’s IEEPA decision
Repealing any reciprocal tariffs placed by President Donald Trump on US imports of direct reduced iron (DRI), iron ore, hot-briquetted iron (HBI), and pig iron would have only a nominal impact on the US steel market, market participants said.

ITC votes to keep HR duties after sunset review
The US government determined this week that hot-rolled steel imports from a handful of countries continue to threaten the domestic steel industry.