Steel Mills
USW remains skeptical of USS acquisition despite Nippon's promises
Written by Ethan Bernard
February 26, 2024
The United Steelworkers (USW) union said it doesn’t trust assurances from Japan’s Nippon Steel Corp. (NSC) that it will support labor contracts after its acquisition of U.S. Steel.
“We have never taken comfort from a company that says, ‘Trust us,’” the union said in letter dated Monday, Feb. 26.
The letter was signed signed by USW International President David McCall. It was also signed by Mike Millsap, director and chairman of the USW’s negotiating committee as well as director of District 7, which represents steelworkers in Indiana, Illinois, and Wisconsin.
Nippon letter
The USW statement was in response to a letter Nippon had written on Feb. 13 and that was filed today on a website dedicated to the deal.
“We understand that a change in ownership can create anxiety for the USW and its members,” Takahiro Mori, Nippon EVP and representative director, said in the letter addressed to McCall and Millsap. “However, I want to assure the USW and its members that NSC stands behind the USW agreements.”
The letter goes on to list benefits of the deal – including large increases in revenue, net income, and creditworthiness – for the combined company.
USW response
In heated language, the USW responded: “A promise from Nippon Steel, however – a Japanese corporation that is not authorized to do business in the United States – isn’t worth the paper it is printed on.”
USW went on to describe the possible difficulty of bringing Nippon to court in the event USW thought their agreements had been breached.
“Today, if we have a contractual dispute with USS that continues beyond arbitration, we can sue USS in US courts to enforce our agreements,” USW said.
“If Nippon Steel assumes our agreements, but hides behind its US shell company Nippon Steel North America, our ability to enforce our agreements and to collect on the company’s negotiated obligations will diminish,” the union added.
USW continued: “We as union members don’t deal in trust. We base our decisions on enforceable contracts that protect our employment security, our economic security, and our retirement security.”
A spokesperson for U.S. Steel said the acquisition by Nippon Steel would be good for all stakeholders. “Nippon Steel’s investment in U. S. Steel will strengthen the American steel industry for the benefit of American customers, employees, and communities,” they said.
“In addition to honoring all collective-bargaining agreements currently in place with the unions, Nippon Steel has pledged that no jobs will be lost as a result of the transaction, it will maintain the iconic U. S. Steel name and branding, and it will keep the Pittsburgh headquarters,” the spokesperson added.
Finally, the statement said: “We welcome the review of our transaction by relevant regulatory bodies, and we are committed to delivering shared success as we turn U. S. Steel into the best and most innovative steel company in America.”
The proposed deal, valued at almost $15 billion, was first announced in December, and now faces regulatory hurdles.
New NDA
Separately on Monday, a report in Bloomberg announced that a nondisclosure agreement (NDA) had been signed by the USW and Nippon in order to “advance talks.” No further discussions had taken place between the two, though, the article said.
A spokesperson for Nippon confirmed to SMU that the NDA had been signed but had no further comment.
Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Steel Mills
SDI guides toward lower Q3 earnings on weaker flat-rolled steel prices
Steel Dynamics Inc. (SDI) expects lower third-quarter earnings on the heels of “meaningfully lower” prices at its flat-rolled steel operations. The Fort Wayne, Ind.-based steelmaker expects Q3’24 earnings of $1.94 to $1.98 per diluted share, according to figures released on Monday. That’s down from $2.72 per share in Q2’24 and down from $3.47 per share in Q3’23.
Stelco shareholders OK $2.5B sale to Cliffs
Stelco shareholders voted overwhelmingly on Monday to OK the $2.5-billion sale of the Canadian flat-rolled steelmaker to Cleveland-Cliffs. Indeed, 99.97% of those who cast ballots voted to approve the deal, according the Hamilton, Ontario-based steelmaker.
White House may delay decision on USS-Nippon deal until after election: report
The White House decision on blocking Nippon Steel’s play for Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel might be pushed back until after the upcoming presidential election, according to a report in the Washington Post.
Hybar lands ‘strategic’ investment from Quanta Services
Hybar said that contracting services firm Quanta Services has made a “strategic” investment in the company as it build its sustainable rebar mill in northeast Arkansas.
Cliffs to place C-6 furnace at Cleveland Works on hot idle: sources
Cleveland-Cliffs plans to place the C-6 blast furnace at its Cleveland Works in Ohio on hot idle in October, according to sources familiar with the matter.