Steel Mills

USS confirms split CFIUS decision on Nippon deal; it's now up to Biden
Written by Laura Miller
December 23, 2024
The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) could not reach a unanimous decision on whether Nippon Steel’s proposed $14.9-billion purchase of the iconic U.S. Steel poses a national security threat.
The committee’s split decision pushes it to the president for the final call. By law, President Biden has 15 days to render a ruling. This pushes back the decision on the deal’s fate into the new year, to Tuesday, Jan. 7, just two weeks before Biden’s presidency ends and Trump’s second term begins. It will also be well over a year since the deal was first announced in December 2023.
The national security concern identified by CFIUS is that Nippon’s acquisition of U.S. Steel could lead to lower domestic steel production, the Washington Post reported.
U.S. Steel confirmed receipt of the CFIUS decision late Monday.
“It is our hope that President Biden will do the right thing and adhere to the law by approving a transaction that so clearly enhances U.S. national and economic security,” the Pittsburgh-based steelmaker said in a statement to SMU.
“Nippon Steel has made extraordinary commitments, including over $2.7 billion of investments in our USW facilities, that will be a binding legal agreement enforceable by the U.S. government, to ensure these virtues are realized,” USS pointed out.
“This is a transaction that should be approved on its merits, and one that should be a model for “friendshoring” investment,” it added.
While Biden has said U.S. Steel should remain an American company, it’s been reported that he will nix the deal. Trump has stated the same.
Attorneys for Nippon and U.S. Steel told CFIUS they would “immediately” challenge a Biden ruling to block the deal and to expect civil lawsuits against the administration, according to the Washington Post report.
Nippon Steel did not respond to an SMU request for comment.
USW unmoved
The United Steelworkers (USW) union, critical of the deal since it was first announced, remains unmoved in its opposition to Nippon’s takeover of the US steelmaker.
In a Christmas Eve statement, union leadership reminded members that Nippon initially was only interested in purchasing U.S. Steel’s Big River Steel assets in Arkansas.
“That continues to be the long-term focus of its acquisition,” USW said. “The result would be the gradual starving of capital to other operations around the country, the likely loss of our jobs, and the negative impact on our country’s economic and national security.
“It is solely the president’s responsibility to review CFIUS’s report and make the determination,” it continued. “Now it’s up to President Biden to determine the best path forward.”

Laura Miller
Read more from Laura MillerLatest in Steel Mills

Despite trade chaos, Barry Schneider upbeat on SDI, steel
With 30 years of experience at Steel Dynamics, Barry Schneider reflects on the company and the state of the steel industry.

Algoma Steel seeks CAD$500M in operational support
Algoma Steel applied to Canada’s federal Large Enterprise Tariff Loan (LETL) program for $500 million to support its long-term operations.

SDI concerned with potential Brazil pig iron tariffs
Steel Dynamics Inc. (SDI) executives called a 50% tariff on Brazilian pig iron “concerning,” but think tariffs will be a “mainstay” of trade agreements going forward.

SDI earnings slip in Q2 as trade volatility hits customer orders
SDI profits slipped in second quarter amid trade policy volatility.

Cliffs puts ‘for sale’ signs up after another big quarterly loss
Cleveland-Cliffs lost more than $400 million for the third consecutive quarter but predicted results would improve in the second half of the year. And shares of the Cleveland-based steelmaker surged after company executives said during its Q2 earnings call on Monday that they could make billions by courting foreign investors or selling assets.