Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by John Packard
November 30, 2015
For our U.S. customers, welcome back from the Thanksgiving Holiday. We are a little more than three weeks from our next break for the Christmas and New Year Holidays. Then we plow into 2016 and my gut tells me by then things may begin to change. We still have our SMU Price Momentum Indicator pointing toward lower flat rolled steel prices but, well, we will wait and see what happens as scrap negotiations get underway for December (and snow flies in the Midwest)…
I was sorry to see the email from the General Manager of CRU’s steel business who informed me on Thanksgiving Day that they would no longer support our re-publishing of their hot rolled, cold rolled, galvanized and plate indices. They told us, “Our view is that publishing our prices to potential customers, for what is a small sum of money, is not to our advantage.” They also advised us that they will enforce their copyright, “…Copyright on our prices is something we are pursuring (sic) vigorously and this has proven costly for some people who did not take it seriously…” So, there you have it.
In the future we will no longer reference CRU on our website or in our newsletter. Not because of the threat of a lawsuit (which they made quite clear they would, so my lawyers are already involved) but because there are other options out there and we will leave that up to the steel community to decide what works best for each relationship and what is the most transparent and trustworthy for your needs.
To be fair to CRU they did tell me that they did not have any problems with SMU or me personally. This was a business decision on their part. I hold no ill will toward CRU as they have a right to run their business as they wish.
The relationship between CRU and SMU officially ends on December 17th. You are welcome to voice your views on the subject which you can do by sending me an email: John@SteelMarketUpdate.com.
I already am working on something to replace CRU that I think will bring more value to our readers, as the real goal is to be able to view the movement of prices and trust the rate of change at any point in the marketplace. I think our own flat rolled steel indices have proven themselves to be reliable against all of the other indexes but I continue to prefer that it not be used in financial transactions. This might change in the future should we decide to grow our staff and our ability to index a wider variety of products. The marketplace will determine whether there is a need (and a willingness to pay a reasonable fee for the service). Again, you can voice your opinion by sending me an email.
I want to take a moment to welcome both our newest member companies as well as the large group of people who have opted to trial our product. I want to remind everyone that we are receptive to receiving questions, comments and suggestions from anyone who is interacting with our newsletter or website. You can reach us at: info@SteelMarketUpdate.com and we will answer your queries to the best of our abilities.
As always your business is truly appreciated by all of us here at Steel Market Update.
John Packard, Publisher
John Packard
Read more from John PackardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Who could’ve guessed that the first stage to follow liberation would be confusion. Well, when things get this liberated this fast, perhaps it’s to be expected. From the 30,000-foot view, “Liberation Day” didn’t have a significant impact on steel tariff-wise. That is, the Section 232 steel and aluminum tariffs stand alone from the reciprocal tariffs […]
Final Thoughts
The market breathlessly awaits the arrival of President Trump's "Liberation Day."
Final Thoughts
I’m not sure what I can write today that won’t be old news after April 2. The Trump administration has dubbed Wednesday “Liberation Day.” Since it’s mostly about tariffs, let’s just call it “Tariff Day.” Or maybe we should call it “Tariff Week” – since tariffs typically dominate the news cycle in the first week […]
Final Thoughts
A personal perspective on Galvalume prices from SMU analyst Brett Linton.
Final Thoughts
After a March frenzy, are prices nearing a peak in April? Some of you have suggested that they are. Others think it's too early to make any such call.