• Skip to main content

    Analysis

    Final Thoughts

    Written by John Packard


    The Bureau of Industry and Security today denied the exclusion exemptions for two mills: California Steel Industries and Evraz. At this point, we are expecting the NLMK USA and JSW USA exclusion requests to be denied as well. However, a trade attorney (not Lewis) suggested that we not move too fast with any proclamations. There are some interesting circumstances associated with the JSW request. JSW, unlike the other re-rollers, is in the process of building a new EAF at their Baytown, Texas, plate and pipe plant and they just refurbished an idle EAF at Mingo Junction facilities. The Mingo Junction EAF is producing slabs for their hot strip mill and has been up and running for a couple of months now. NLMK also owns a mill that produces steel for their Portage, Ind., facility, and they are buying slabs from U.S. Steel.

    John Packard Summit 18Today, I recruited another attorney to be on our trade panel for the 2019 SMU Steel Summit Conference. Alan Price of Wiley Rein LLP, a firm that represents the domestic steel industry, will join Phil Bell, president of the Steel Manufacturers Association, and trade attorney Lewis Leibowitz along with one yet-to-be-named panelist. I am looking at this panel to be in a debate format as opposed to long statements. There will be much to cover regarding trade when we get to late August. About the only thing that’s sure about trade and trade policy – expect the unexpected.

    Latest in Analysis

    Alacero Summit rundown: China pressure sharpens calls for steel protection, regional cooperation

    Mexico and Latin America need a stronger response to subsidized steel and manufacturing overcapacity, according to speakers at Alacero Summit 2026. “What we cannot do is compete against a state,” said Máximo Vedoya, Ternium CEO, in his opening remarks. Vedoya maintained that Latin American (Latam) steelmakers can compete in the international landscape under fair conditions, but state-backed competition requires a stronger policy response. Laying the groundwork Across all conference sessions, a recurring theme emerged: governments should move beyond diagnosing unfair competition and use trade enforcement more assertively, with US action under the Trump administration providing one example. Talks about global overcapacity and dumping of subsidized Chinese and Indian steel in Latam and calls for broader government partnership to protect regional steelmaking and industry dominated the event last week in Mexico City.

    SMU Survey: Steel buyers turn to imports as lead times stretch and prices rise

    Amid stable to improving demand (see Slide 26), steel buyers report extended lead times and elevated prices, while imports remain a competitive option, according to SMU’s latest survey results. Most service centers and manufacturers responding to our survey said foreign offers were competitive, and many reported placing new orders for future delivery. As reported last week, sheet product lead times continue to lengthen, with most reaching their highest levels since the post-Covid demand snapback in 2021 (Slide 14). Hot-rolled (HR) coil lead times are averaging 9.7 weeks at domestic mills, according to our survey.

    steel coils

    October service center shipments and inventories report

    US service centers’ flat-rolled steel supply increased marginally for a second straight month in October. Shipping days of supply rose to 46.6 last month, according to SMU data. That figure marks a 1.7% increase from 45.9 shipping days in September. October’s result represents continued modest gains after inventories hit a five-year low in August. Despite the uptick, inventories are nearly 13% below October 2025 levels. Sheet inventories have averaged ~48 shipping days of supply year-to-date, down nearly 17% over the same year-ago period. Flat-rolled inventories represented 2.12 months of supply in October, down 3.0% from 2.18 in September, and 8.6% below October 2025’s 2.32 months. The month-on-month (m/m) decline in months of supply resulted from a decline (-9.6%) in intake that was backed by a modest 4.1% m/m increase in shipments.

    Price: Blue wave may rock tariff boat, but some ships like Section 232 aren’t sinking

    The midterms are over, and Democrats will control both chambers of Congress in January. In this space last week, Lewis Leibowitz predicted that President Trump's tariffs, including Section 232, may not last much longer. We disagree. To be sure, the new Congress will change trade policy. It will hold hearings, write bills, and almost certainly revisit the trade dispute with Canada. But the foundation of US trade policy is unlikely to be disturbed. Section 232 and Section 301 are established, court-tested authorities that both parties have used. They are also working.