• Skip to main content

    Final Thoughts

    Final Thoughts: Longer waits, higher stakes

    Written by David Schollaert


    We’re in rarefied air for the US domestic steel industry. Mill lead times are approaching or even exceeding (in the case of plate) records set in 2021. Prices, meanwhile, are on an epic run—13 months and counting.

    Availability, not price, is the largest hurdle buyers are facing. And market participants think the shortage could stay around for a while.

    Incoming imports and mills catching up after fall maintenance could ease the squeeze. Even so, most sources do not expect meaningful relief until 2027, and some don’t think it will come until next spring or summer.

    And just when you think it couldn’t get any tighter, the supply squeeze gets ratcheted up another notch. Michael Cowden touched on it in last week’s Final Thoughts: Is the market tighter than it was in 2021?

    The answer? A resounding “YES!” from market sources and respondents to our latest steel market survey.

    How tight is too tight?

    It makes me think of a joke my late paternal grandfather—a 40-year veteran of Pittsburgh Steel Company’s Allenport Works—enjoyed telling.

    For brevity’s sake, here’s a quick summary of the joke:

    A man plagued by dizziness, lightheadedness, and blurred vision visits a doctor. After a slew of inconclusive tests, the doctor gives him six months to live.

    Distraught but determined to make the most of what’s left, the man decides to live like a king. He quits his job, books a luxury cruise, and visits a tailor for a new wardrobe.

    He walks into the high-end tailor shop. The tailor takes one look at the man’s neck.

    “You need a size 16 and a half collar,” the tailor says.

    “Nonsense. I’ve always worn a 15,” the man exclaims.

    “Suit yourself—but you’ll get dizzy, lightheaded, and your vision will blur.”

    What’s my point with the joke? Honestly? Just a good laugh!

    Am I suggesting the market doesn’t recognize that things are tight? No, I’m not saying that. It’s tight—the tightest most of us have ever seen.

    I spoke to an industry veteran, a real “lion of steel,” who doesn’t recall the market being this tight since the early 1970s.

    The state of play

    But back to some of what’s driving the market now.

    Name a mill, and it likely had a maintenance outage this fall. Most outages have now come and gone, but a couple of significant ones remain.

    And even though we’re on the other side of many of those outages, we’re still seeing a market characterized by long lead times, production backlogs, delays, and surging prices.

    Right now, if a mill publishes its lead times, it might have “inquire” instead of dates. Come to think of it, reporting lead times almost requires a PhD in physics, cosmology, and general relativity. Why? Because the date a buyer submits an order and the date a mill acknowledges it can feel light years apart.

    “Reporting lead times is not as cut and dry as it has been in the past,” a service center source said. “Some are running anywhere between two and four months behind before orders are acknowledged.”

    “It’s really ridiculous in terms of material planning,” the source added.

    The result of ridiculously extended lead times? Higher prices, double buying, and hefty premiums even on the secondary market.

    Tip the scales

    Speaking of prices, SMU’s price assessment for spot hot-rolled (HR) coil stands at $1,305 per short ton (st) on average, up $15/st from last week and up $485/st from a year ago. That’s if you can even find a domestic mill with spot availability.

    We’re hearing of hot band prices as high as $1,400/st for 150-400 st orders. We’re also hearing of resale prices as high as $1,800/st–1,900/st.

    We’re told nearly all spot order books are closed for 2026. Some mills have started offering 2027 spot tons. But again, volumes are incredibly limited.

    What comes next?

    Demand remains solid. In general, we continue to hear that things are steady to up in more traditional sectors. Meanwhile, things are running white hot in non-traditional markets like data centers and the border wall. And the companies building data centers don’t worry about prices nearly as much as traditional buyers do. It’s yet another factor pushing prices higher.

    Where the market goes from here depends on who you ask. On the one hand, some sources say that if demand improves in auto and traditional construction markets, the current squeeze would pale in comparison. On the other hand, others think incoming imports could contribute to a supply overhang.

    What are you seeing out there? Let me know.

    And thanks to all of you for your continued support of SMU. We truly appreciate it.

    David Schollaert

    Read more from David Schollaert

    Latest in Final Thoughts

    Final Thoughts: Do Mesabi Metallics and Hyundai-POSCO signal more foreign steel investment in US?

    Could two new steel projects signal a new direction in the marketplace? Both Mesabi Metallics’ recently announced steel facility in Iowa and the Hyundai-POSCO’s proposed mill in Louisiana are major undertakings. You don’t spitball a major steel mill and then start producing the next day. From initial concept to site selection and on up to the first melt, there is a labyrinth of permitting, planning, and construction to navigate before the first heat.

    Michael Cowden, SMU Team

    Final Thoughts: Steel prices soar despite stock market turmoil, Republican shellacking

    Republicans got shellacked in the midterms on Tuesday. Equities got shellacked on Wall St. on Thursday. And steel prices continued upward as if nothing had happened. I asked a couple of weeks ago whether the supply squeeze we’re seeing now is more intense than what we saw in 2021. It’s becoming increasingly clear that it is by most metrics, with the notable exception of price. Don’t believe me? Read our exclusive interview with Worthington Steel President and CEO Geoff Gilmore. If you take away just one quote, this is it: "I’ve been in the business for 28 years, and this is the toughest market that I’ve encountered," Gilmore told SMU.

    Final Thoughts: Is the steel market now tighter than in 2021?

    "Now, the problem is no longer the price. The problem is having access to steel." That would have made a good lead. But I can’t take credit for it. Those (very quotable) words are from Cleveland-Cliffs Chairman and CEO Lourenco Goncalves during the steelmaker’s quarterly earnings conference call on Monday. For a while, I thought the shortages we'd been hearing about might be mostly a problem for small- and mid-sized buyers. But we’re seeing even some of the biggest steel buyers talking openly about supply problems.