SMU Data and Models
Steel Buyers Basics: Painted Steel – Service Centers, Mills, Toll Processors & Paint Companies
Written by Mario Briccetti
December 22, 2013
Of the three main ways of procuring prepainted flat rolled steel described in my last article, buying from a service center is the simplest. Service Centers will quote a price that can be compared apples to apples against one other. In addition a good Service Center can consult on the correct specifications and will also handle your inventory, slitting and sheeting requirements. In short the Service Center will manage the program for the steel buyer but in return, the Service Center commands a margin on the business and gets to keep any supplier rebates, which can be substantial. More on rebates in a moment.
A painted steel deal becomes somewhat more complex when buying directly from a steel mill. Steel mills will need complete specifications on both the steel and the paint required. If the buyer specifies the paint he can also negotiate a direct rebate with the paint supplier based on the volume of painted steel (and perhaps the type and color of paint). Pricing then becomes a matter of the delivered cost of the painted steel plus whatever rebate the paint company is willing to give. Furthermore, Steel Mills that paint their own steel (like Steel Dynamics, Ternium or Steelscape) will often give the buyer an additional rebate based on the volume of painted coil.
Note that mills often have large minimum run quantities for a particular color and type of paint, tend to have long lead-times and are generally not very flexible when it comes to making changes in the schedules.
The most complex type of deal is when a buyer uses a toll-processor to paint coils owned by the buyer’s company. Here the buyer must first negotiate a deal with a Steel Mill for the price of the steel substrate to be painted, then a separate deal with the toll-processor regarding painting costs and scrap factors and then a final rebate deal with the paint supplier. Now the delivered price becomes the cost of the steel, plus the cost of the painting the steel, plus the cost of the scrap generated by the toll-processor during the painting process, plus the freight involved less any rebates the buyer can negotiate from the Steel Mill, the toll-processor and the paint supplier.
The Toll-processor deal has a lot of moving parts the buyer must keep track of but there are some important advantages to this type of deal. Toll-processors are generally more flexible when changes in demand occur and for a buyer needing many different colors this flexibility can be very important. Also Toll-processors act as the buyer’s quality control arm, ensuring the steel and paint meet specifications. Finally the larger Toll-processors have plants around the country and since freight on steel is a big consideration this can be a significant cost advantage.
Another use for a Toll-processor is to paint foreign steel. Buying foreign painted steel is problematic for high-end paint that carries a long-term warranty. A buyer can still source foreign steel, have it delivered to a Toll-processor who will store it and then paint it as required. Finally Toll-processors are agnostic when it comes to paint and steel suppliers and that means they (if asked to) will help the buyer figure out whose product is best for their particular application.
One last thing with Toll-processors though, the steel they hold is not theirs and the scrap they generate will be paid for by the buyer and may be a hidden cost. Buyers should make sure they negotiate limits on this scrap level and that it is tracked and that they receive scrap credit for it. Finally for certain large customers some mills, who do not paint steel themselves, will create a single-payer price (for a fee) that includes the Toll-processor scrap and coating costs.
Next time further details on rebates for painted steel.
SMU Note: Mario Briccetti is the Principal of Briccetti & Associates a consulting firm dealing with supply chain. Previously he held vice president level or lead steel purchasing positions at Nordyne, Gibraltar Strip Steel and Metal Sales Manufacturing Corp. Mario can be reached at: Mario@MBriccetti.com
Mario Briccetti
Read more from Mario BriccettiLatest in SMU Data and Models
SMU Survey: Buyers’ Sentiment tumbles as caution increases
SMU’s Buyers’ Sentiment Indices resumed their downward trend this week, erasing the modest recovery seen two weeks ago.
Service centers: Mill orders down further in April
SMU’s Mill Order Index (MOI) declined for a second straight month in April after repeated gains at the start of the year, according to our latest service center inventories data.
SMU Survey: Mill lead times edge lower
Sheet and plate lead times declined across the board this week, according to buyers responding to the latest SMU market survey. While our lead time ranges were unchanged compared to mid-April levels, average production times for each steel product we measure have declined from they were two weeks ago.
SMU Survey: Most buyers say price negotiations back on the table
Domestic mills are largely negotiable on spot prices, according to the majority of steel buyers responding to our latest market survey.
SMU Scrap Survey: Current, Future Sentiment Indices log declines
However, in a month plagued by tariff and economic uncertainty, both current and near-term outlooks for our scrap survey respondents remained surprisingly optimistic.