Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by John Packard
December 2, 2015
Tonight I thought I would present a question posed to me within the past couple of days and ask for your input in answering the question. How would you respond to this?
Has the steel industry in the US stopped following laws of economics or are we living the great delusion of “ok” demand? Consider the following facts:
1. Steel imports into US have trended down from June thru Oct meanwhile domestic production has also fallen –> suggests demand slowness
2. Despite trade cases and relatively few tons of steel actually coming from China, US steel mills have not tried raising prices
3. Service center shipments have trended down from spring onward and inventory levels are relatively high with MoS at around 2.8 – 3.0
4. From demand perspective – auto is doing well and construction is doing okay and these account for 60-70% of steel demand in USA
5. Assuming, turmoil in Machinery/Energy .. demand might have slackened by 5-7 MM tonnes (annualized) but idled mills account for ~ 4-5 MM tonnes
Will appreciate your thoughts. Am I underestimating the machinery/energy/other industry impact?
You can respond by sending an email to me directly: John@SteelMarketUpdate.com. You are also welcome to contact my office by phone if you are more comfortable speaking with me directly: 800-432-3475.
We will be reporting on the ongoing scrap negotiations in Sunday evening’s newsletter. Will poor demand at the steel mills trump slowing collection rates?
As always your business is truly appreciated by all of us here at Steel Market Update.
John Packard, Publisher
John Packard
Read more from John PackardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final thoughts
Cleveland-Cliffs is seeking $750 per short ton (st) for hot-rolled coil. That’s $20/st above where the steelmaker had been. It’s also $30/st above Nucor, which is at $720/st this week. We've seen prices increase incrementally this week. SMU's HR price, for example, stands at $690/st on average, up $5/st from last week. The questions now are whether a number well above $700/st will stick, whether other mills will follow Cliffs, and whether there is enough demand to support higher prices.
Final thoughts
We got a little flack for adjusting our sheet momentum indicators to neutral last week. To be clear, we didn’t adjust them to lower. Part of the reason we moved them to neutral was because there are some unusual cross-currents in the current market. On the news side, you could make a case that there should nowhere to go but up.
Final thoughts
I think all of us know that sometimes courtships go wrong. A misplaced word or deed and soon things can go sideways, and not in the prices sense. Such could be the case with Japanese steelmaker Nippon Steel’s play for U.S. Steel.
Final thoughts
We’re starting to see some impacts of the big trade case filed last week against imports of coated flat-rolled steel from 10 nations. Namely, we’ve heard that a range of traders have stopped offering material from Vietnam. An alleged dumping margin of nearly 160% will do that. Especially amid chatter of critical circumstances.
Final thoughts
The phrase “political football” has been tossed around a lot lately. (Pun probably intended.) For the humble journalists at SMU who thought the week following Steel Summit would prove a quiet one… the news cycle had other ideas