Trade Cases

WTO Members Critical of U.S. National Security Measures
Written by Sandy Williams
July 10, 2018
The World Trade Organization is keeping busy fielding complaints from countries concerned about U.S. trade policies. So far seven countries have filed requests to the WTO for consultation with the U.S. on Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminum.
Russia was the latest to file a complaint, charging that the Section 232 measures violate WTO rules under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the Agreement on Safeguards. Norway, Mexico, Canada, the EU, India and China have filed similar complaints claiming that the U.S. tariffs are safeguards rather than national security measures.
Other WTO members, such as Hong Kong, Thailand and Turkey, have not filed their own disputes, but have asked to be third parties to the consultations.
U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer has pushed back on the safeguard argument, maintaining that under GATT “each sovereign country must have the power to decide, for itself, what actions are essential to its security.”
“Rather than work with the United States, [the EU and others] have retaliated with tariffs designed to punish U.S. companies and workers,” said Lighthizer. “In an effort to give cover to this blatant disregard for WTO rules, they claim to be acting in reliance on a narrow exception that applies only in response to a safeguard measure. That exception does not apply here, however, because the United States has not taken a safeguard measure.”
The Section 232 measures on steel and aluminum, as well as proposed measures on autos exported to the U.S., were central to discussions at the WTO Goods Council meeting in Geneva last week. GATT issues fall under the purview of the Goods Council. Members at the meeting discussed how the U.S. measures will affect global value chains, consumer costs and the multilateral trading system.
Members struggled to see how U.S. national security could be threatened by the import of automobiles and auto parts. Over 40 WTO members spoke at the meeting, warning that imposing auto tariffs could seriously disrupt the global market and multilateral trading system.
Russia, which along with Japan initiated the auto tariff discussions at the meeting, said the U.S. is losing its reputation as a trusted trading partner by threatening the rules of the global trading system. Japan postulated that auto tariffs would lead to an avalanche of retaliatory measures.

Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Trade Cases

Trump to announce 25% tariffs on all steel, aluminum imports on Monday
President Donald Trump said he would announce 25% tariffs on all steel and aluminum imported to the US, according to Bloomberg. Trump said he would make an announcement about the matter on Monday. It was not clear when the tariffs might take effect.

Price: What another round on the tariff carousel means for US trade policy
The day-to-day bustle of these announcements should not obscure what they signal for other potential tariff measures in the near term and a revamped trade and economic policy in the long term.

Commerce sets initial CVDs of 0-140% in coated steel trade case
The Commerce Department on Tuesday issued preliminary subsidy rates in the corrosion-resistant steel (CORE) trade case. The agency set minimal countervailing duty (CVD) rates for Brazil and Mexico, mostly high rates for Vietnam, and low rates for Canada, except for one privately held distributor. Commerce assigned that company, Nova Steel, and a handful of Vietnamese […]

Tampa Steel Conference: Trade attorney says brace for turbulence
Steel and aluminum have been identified as high priorities for trade

Trudeau, Trump agree to push tariffs until March
Canada fights back, a little As this article was about to be posted, Canada had not backed down to US President Trump’s 25% tariffs coming for Canadian goods at the stroke of midnight. In fact, the Government of Canada had pushed back, saying it would implement 25% tariffs on $155 billion worth of US products […]