• Skip to main content

    Analysis

    Final Thoughts

    Written by John Packard


    I have noticed many articles in the mainline press over the past few days slamming the Trump administration’s Section 232 tariffs as not helping the steel industry. Most of the articles point to the recent loss announced by U.S. Steel as proof, along with minimal to no job gains in the industry. I don’t think those writing the articles have spent much time looking at the investments announced by multiple mills, including U.S. Steel, and the impact this new capacity will have on the future competitiveness of the industry. Sure, there will be pain to come for those mills that are unable or unwilling to make investments in their future with new equipment. There will be older mills needing to close in order to make way for the new mills being built. The tariffs, along with antidumping and countervailing duties, have limited imports and allowed the steel mills some breathing room. Where the industry goes from here will depend on demand, both here and in the rest of the world.

    John Packard Summit 18In case you missed it, I have raised our Price Momentum Indicator on all flat rolled products from Neutral to Higher. This means SMU anticipates prices on hot rolled, cold rolled, galvanized and Galvalume to move higher over the next 30 days. The market is still in transition, and we did see some weakness in cold rolled and galvanized based on the information gathered from our survey so far this week. However, I do not believe the low numbers provided are still available in the market and may be more reflective of last week’s pricing. We will continue to work on better understanding steel prices as the rest of the week plays out.

    Latest in Analysis

    Price: Blue wave may rock tariff boat, but some ships like Section 232 aren’t sinking

    The midterms are over, and Democrats will control both chambers of Congress in January. In this space last week, Lewis Leibowitz predicted that President Trump's tariffs, including Section 232, may not last much longer. We disagree. To be sure, the new Congress will change trade policy. It will hold hearings, write bills, and almost certainly revisit the trade dispute with Canada. But the foundation of US trade policy is unlikely to be disturbed. Section 232 and Section 301 are established, court-tested authorities that both parties have used. They are also working.

    SMU Survey: Current and Future Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices rise

    SMU’s Current and Future Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices increased this week, according to our latest market survey.   Every two weeks, SMU polls thousands of steel-industry executives, asking them to rate their companies’ chances of success today and also three to six months down the road. We use their responses to calculate our proprietary Current and Future Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices, measures tracked since 2008.

    US heating and cooling shipments fall for third straight month

    US shipments of heating and cooling equipment slipped in September for a third consecutive month, according to the latest data from the Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI). Shipments declined 2.6% month on month (m/m) in September, after having fallen 10% m/m in August. The monthly pace marks the third-slowest shipment rate year to date. Historically, shipments are strongest in early summer and weakest around the turn of the year, driven by seasonal air conditioner and heat pump volumes. AHRI's data shows September shipments totaled 1,687,240 units, down 2.6% m/m but up 7.7% year over year (y/y) (Figure 1, left). From August to September, shipments of warm air furnaces, A/C, and heat pumps declined, while water heater shipments rose. Compared with a year earlier, only air conditioners and heat pump shipments were higher.