• Skip to main content

    Government/Policy

    July 9, 2019

    Leibowitz on Trade: Mercatus Report on Steel Exclusions Process Finds Worrisome Trends

    Written by Lewis Leibowitz

    Trade attorney and Steel Market Update contributor Lewis Leibowitz offers the following update on events in Washington:

    Companies have filed thousands of requests seeking exclusions from the Trump administration’s Section 232 tariffs on steel imports, claiming the products they require are not available from domestic sources in the quantities or qualities required. The steel product exclusion process has come under increased scrutiny revealing noteworthy inconsistencies in Commerce’s decision-making and procedures. The Mercatus Center at George Mason University in Virginia has studied the steel exclusion process and decisions through exhaustive analysis. They have calculated the amount of steel products that large domestic producers have claimed the ability to produce. In one instance, with respect to Nucor, George Mason determined that the company objected to exclusion requests totaling 41.31 million metric tons, but that their annual production amounted to a bit more than 24 million metric tons. AK Steel objected to requests for over 30 million metric tons, but only produces about 6 million. Yet only 1 percent of exclusion requests receiving objections are approved by Commerce.

    Lewis Leibowitz, SMU Contributor

    Lewis Leibowitz

    Lewis Leibowitz, owner of the Law Office of Lewis E. Leibowitz, practices in the areas of international trade law, customs law, and international commercial transactions. He represents clients before all federal courts and agencies dealing with international trade matters. Mr. Leibowitz advises and assists clients in diverse matters including trade remedies, customs, foreign-trade zones and free trade agreements, trade negotiations, and related matters. He can be reached at lewis.leibowitz@lellawoffice.com.

    Read more from Lewis Leibowitz

    Latest in Government/Policy

    Price on Trade: Steel’s zero-sum game

    During the first three quarters of 2026, finished steel imports from South Korea increased 50.8% compared with the same period in 2025. Imports from Vietnam increased 23.4%, imports from Turkey increased 49.5%, and imports from India increased 29.5%. Those are not marginal increases. They are substantial import surges, especially in a US market where apparent domestic consumption has bounced around but has not grown since 2017. More importantly, these import surges are arriving at lower average unit values (AUVs).

    Commerce updates duties on Japanese HR

    The US Department of Commerce has adjusted anti-dumping duties on imports of hot-rolled flat steel products from Japan. The adjustment has lowered duties for one company but raised them for others. Commerce made the adjustments in the final results of an administrative review of the year ended Sept. 30, 2024. The agency set a final weighted-average dumping margin of 13.96% for Nippon Steel companies. This is lower than the company’s previous rate of 29.7%.

    Leibowitz: US steel prices skyrocket above world prices. Which are right?

    Steel markets in the United States now feature supply shortages. Spot tons are well-nigh unavailable, and even contract tons are scarce. Based on the available statistics, the US market for flat-rolled products is seriously constrained. The US economy is still the strongest in the world, and manufacturing output remains vigorous. But the available supply is tight. The reason is fairly obvious. US domestic supply has increased a bit. Meanwhile, imports have fallen significantly.