• Skip to main content

    Government/Policy

    Leibowitz on Trade: A Dilemma for the Government on Tariff Refunds Found Unlawful?

    Written by Lewis Leibowitz


    Last Tuesday, the Court of International Trade issued a major opinion in the massive litigation over China tariffs. As I’ve written before, the imposition of tariffs on more than $200 billion of imports per year from China has prompted a slew of lawsuits (more than 3,600 so far, including 6,500 separate plaintiffs), which could find that the List Three and List 4A China tariffs are contrary to Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974. In the lead case on this matter, the government argued that duties later declared unlawful could not be refunded if the Customs entries were closed out administratively (“liquidated”).

    The government has, until now, consistently accepted that in cases subject to the CIT’s “residual” jurisdiction, past entries that were “liquidated” by Customs could be reopened and re-liquidation ordered by the Court of International Trade if the tariffs collected were unlawful and were imposed by the action of other agencies (such as the U.S. Trade Representative in 301 cases and the Commerce Department under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962).

    Lewis Leibowitz, SMU Contributor

    Lewis Leibowitz

    Read more from Lewis Leibowitz

    Latest in Government/Policy

    Canada, China agreement makes room for more Chinese steel

    Canada has extended tariff remissions for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products through Dec. 31, 2028, and expanded coverage to 23 steel and nine aluminum tariff items. The move extends remissions that were due to expire at the end of 2026. The measures apply to products for which Canada says domestic supply is insufficient or unavailable. They apply to 66 lines of product-specific remissions and 49 tariff lines of company-specific remissions. The announcement does not name the newly covered products or quantify their import volumes.

    Alacero Summit rundown: China pressure sharpens calls for steel protection, regional cooperation

    Mexico and Latin America need a stronger response to subsidized steel and manufacturing overcapacity, according to speakers at Alacero Summit 2026. “What we cannot do is compete against a state,” said Máximo Vedoya, Ternium CEO, in his opening remarks. Vedoya maintained that Latin American (Latam) steelmakers can compete in the international landscape under fair conditions, but state-backed competition requires a stronger policy response.

    Commerce postpones final decision in UAE OCTG case

    The Commerce Department has decided to postpone its final determination in the anti-dumping case investigating imports of oil country tubular goods (OCTG) from the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The postponement follows a request from Ajmal Steel Tubes and Pipes Industries, a mandatory respondent in the case. The final determination was slated for January but will now be delayed until mid-March 2027. This aligns the case with the companion investigations of Austria and Taiwan.

    Join SMU on Tuesday for a Community Chat with SMA President Philip K. Bell

    Philip K. Bell, president of the Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA), will join SMU for a Community Chat on Tuesday, Nov. 17. The live webinar is free for anyone to attend. The recording and slide decks will be available only to SMU subscribers. Bell is plugged into steel and plugged into DC politics, which makes this chat a must-see, especially as we prepare for a new, Democratic-controlled Congress to convene in January.