Final Thoughts
Final thoughts
Written by Ethan Bernard
November 30, 2023
Following the United Auto Workers (UAW) union strike, organized labor is enjoying a moment.
After negotiating hefty raises for workers, UAW President Shawn Fain has made explicit his push to unionize non-union auto workers in the US. The question is, could something similar happen in steel?
Sometimes even things set in stone are liable to change. That brings us to U.S. Steel’s Granite City Works in southern Illinois, just across the state line from St. Louis. Whatever you might think of that transition, the mill has been around a long time. The plant started operations back in 1895 as Granite City Steel, according to Global Energy Monitor Wiki. It was purchased by U.S. Steel in 1927.
This week, the Pittsburgh-based steelmaker announced it would indefinitely idle steelmaking at the facility. In other words, the ‘B’ blast furnace, which was temporarily idled in September, will join the ‘A’ furnace in being indefinitely idled.
Recall that Granite City has two blast furnaces: ‘A’ and ‘B’. The ‘A’ furnace was indefinitely idled in April 2020, according to SMU’s blast furnace status table.
U.S. Steel also said in early October that it would lay off ~300 workers, a number that has since been reported to have grown to as many as 1,000 workers.
To gauge the impact on the United Steelworkers (USW) union, which represents Granite City, I spoke with the USW’s Mike Millsap on Thursday. He is the director for USW District 7, which serves workers in Indiana, Illinois, and Wisconsin.
I asked first about the elephant in the room, the potential sale of U.S. Steel. (See SMU managing editor Michael Cowden’s piece here.)
When I asked whether the idling at Granite City was related to any possible deal for U.S. Steel, Millsap said the events were “unrelated.”
He also said that though the figure of 1,000 layoffs was inflated. The actual number will be much lower. For starters, it includes the ~300 layoffs already announced.
“It’s not going to be a thousand people,” Millsap said.
I then asked him about the UAW strike, and if their push to unionize non-union workers could have a knock-on effect for steel and for the USW.
“We’ve been doing this for quite some time,” Millsap said. “Our union is diversified. We’ve got chemical, forestry, steel, aluminum, oil, schools – we’re just all over.”
“We’re always pushing and trying to get better at organizing and organizing the non-organized,” he added, noting organizing drives in tires and in steel.
Would that push into steel include EAF steelmakers?
“I think it will, absolutely,” Millsap responded.
Traditionally, most EAF steelmakers – think, for example, North Star Bluescope, Nucor, and Steel Dynamics Inc. (SDI) – are not unionized. They are often newer than integrated mills, located in less union-friendly regions, and their bonus and payout structures often give workers fewer incentives to organize.
With 70% of domestic steelmaking happening at EAFs – most of them long non-union – it’s hard to imagine how that push would play out. But if the post-2020 world has taught us anything, it’s the future can really throw you a curveball.
Finally, when asked if the continued operation of Granite City would be part of any U.S. Steel deal, Millsap said, “I certainly am hopeful for it.”
“Granite City is an old plant. But it can make money, it does make money, and we need to protect steelmaking,” he added.
Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final thoughts
Is it just me, or does it seem like the summer doldrums might have arrived a little early? I could be wrong there. It’s possible we could see a jump in prices should buyers need to step back into the market to restock. I’ll be curious to see what service center inventories are when we update those figures on May 15. In the meantime, just about everyone we survey thinks HR prices have peaked or soon will. (See slide 17 in the April 26 survey.) Lead times have flattened out. And some of you tell me that you’re starting to see signs of them pulling back. (We’ll know more when we update our lead time data on Thursday.)
Final thoughts
Everybody has a plan… until they’ve dealt with volatility in the HRC market. While Mike Tyson’s original quote was about getting punched in the mouth, it’s unlikely the ex-champ has gone many pricing rounds with hot-rolled coil.
Final thoughts
Hold-rolled (HR) prices held roughly steady this week after slipping for much of April. I don’t have any spicy quotes to offer about mostly flat prices. Besides, a lot of the questions I’ve gotten recently have been about demand. Some of you tell me that it’s still stable or improving. Others tell me that it’s suddenly dried up.
Final thoughts
What a difference a month makes. In late March, it seemed like the US hot-rolled (HR) coil market was poised to cycle upward. Large buyers had re-entered the market and placed big orders earlier in the month. Several outages were underway or upcoming. And expectations were that lead times would continue to extend. Cliffs said […]
Final thoughts
I’ve gotten some questions lately about whether the huge gap between domestic hot-rolled coil (HR) prices and those for cold-rolled (CR) and coated is sustainable. I remember being asked similar questions about the wide spread between HR and plate that developed in early 2022. I thought at the time that there was no way that spread could hold. Turned out, I was wrong. That was humbling. And so I’m not going to make any bold predictions this time.