Trade Cases
Commerce rules four countries are unfairly trading tin mill products
Written by Laura Miller
January 5, 2024
On the afternoon of Friday, Jan. 5, the US Department of Commerce issued its final determination in the trade case involving tin mill products from a handful of countries.
The trade case was brought by Cleveland-Cliffs and the United Steelworkers (USW) union last January. Under investigation is the alleged dumping of tin mill products by Canada, China, Germany, South Korea, the Netherlands, Taiwan, Turkey, and the United Kingdom, as well as the subsidization of the imports from China.
In its final ruling, Commerce determined the following dumping rates:
Country | Dumping rate |
Canada | 5.27% |
China | 122.52% (deposit rate set at 111.98%) |
Germany | 6.88% |
South Korea | 0-2.69% |
Netherlands | 0% |
Taiwan | 0% |
Turkey | 0% |
United Kingdom | 0% |
In the CVD portion of the case investigating imports from China, Commerce set the following subsidy rates:
Company | Subsidy rate |
Baoshan Iron & Steel | 649.98% |
Shougang Jingtang United Iron & Steel Co. and related companies | 331.88% |
China-wide entity | 331.88% |
The US International Trade Commission (ITC), the agency responsible for the injury determinations in trade cases, held a final hearing in this trade case on Thursday, Jan. 4. It will make its final injury ruling next month.
Since Commerce determined that the Netherlands, Taiwan, Turkey, and the UK did not dump tin mill steel into the US market, the ITC will not make injury determinations for those countries and imports from there will not face any duties.
Cliffs’ response
Cleveland-Cliffs applauded Commerce’s decision regarding Canada, Germany, South Korea, and China.
“Together with the existing Section 232 tariffs and quotas, these dumping calculations will provide a check against unfairly traded products from all the major sources of tin mill imports,” Cliffs said in a statement.
“With the heightened levels of both geopolitical uncertainty and supply chain disruptions in the world, we continue to expect disturbances in international trade. Today’s outcome should put importers on notice that the United States will not tolerate unfair trade that harms employers, workers and communities,” Cliffs’ chairman, president, and CEO Lourenco Goncalves added.

Laura Miller
Read more from Laura MillerLatest in Trade Cases

Canadian OCTG producers take aim at Mexico, US, others with new trade case
Evraz NA and Welded Tube of Canada have lodged an unfair trade complaint against imports of OCTG.

Price: Reciprocal tariff changes and potential new tariffs for Brazil, Canada, others
Trade issues do not seem poised to leave the headlines anytime soon. And as recent developments show, the administration’s tariff policy remains ever-changing.

Bessent on Vietnam: 20% tariff stands, Section 232 protections apply
US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told reporters that tariffs for Vietnamese imports to the US are 20% and "specific industries" have trade protections under the Section 232 tariffs.

Steel groups welcome passage of budget bill
Steel trade groups praised the passage of the Big Beautiful Bill (BBB) in Congress on Thursday.

Canada moves to curb steel imports with TRQs
Canada has implemented tariff-rate quotas (TRQs) on steel imports to help stabilize its domestic market.