Trade Cases

CRU: Quotas Would Only Add to the Volatility
Written by Tim Triplett
April 18, 2019
Steel interests in North America and the rest of the world are watching intently to see if the Trump administration grants some tariff relief to Canada and Mexico to clear the way for final approval of the new U.S.-Canada-Mexico Trade Agreement. One possible compromise being discussed (albeit one so far opposed by the U.S. trading partners) is replacing the 25 percent Section 232 tariffs on steel with some form of quota.
Speaking during a webinar hosted by CRU and the CME Group earlier today, CRU Principal Analyst Josh Spoores said quotas may help secure the trade agreement, but will only add to the price volatility plaguing the hot rolled market.
What form the quotas might take is still unknown. There is precedent in quotas on South Korean steel, which limit their exports to the U.S. to 70 percent of historical averages. In the case of Canada and Mexico, it’s more likely the quotas would be set at 100 percent of recent shipments so as not to punish the two nations but to prevent a surge of steel into the U.S. once the tariffs were lifted, Spoores said.
Quotas might help secure the NAFTA 2.0 trade agreement, but will only worsen the volatility in steel shipments and pricing, Spoores predicts. In situations where quotas are set by quarter, such as finished steel from South Korea and slabs from Brazil, imports tend to be front-loaded. The result is a dramatic increase in imports and prices in the first month of each quarter, followed by declines in both as the material is processed and released into the market.
“Quotas would lead to much higher volatility throughout the year,” Spoores said.

Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in Trade Cases

Global steel forum sets 2026 framework deadline as US ups pressure on excess capacity
Global steelmakers sounded the alarm Friday over the deepening excess steelmaking capacity crisis. Ministers at the Global Forum on Steel Excess Capacity (GFSEC) in Gqeberha, South Africa, pledged to...

CRU: China’s indirect steel exports find new destination markets
The boom in China’s direct steel exports has not stopped this year, even with a rise in protectionist measures globally. The increase is driven by...

U.S. Steel sues Algoma over iron pellet shipments
U.S. Steel is suing Algoma over the Canadian flat-rolled producer's rejection of iron pellet shipments, arguing it has breached its contract.

US and Canada expect positive outcomes from tariff negotiations
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump told reporters at the White House on Tuesday that they’ll be formulating a trade deal that works for both nations.

Leibowitz: When the shutdown should end
There is no doubt that the current government shutdown reflects the vast divisions between the extremes of American politics, society, and even geography. Almost all Americans agree that government is necessary, but voters disagree...