Trade Cases
CIT Receives Thousands of Lawsuits Over Section 301 Tariffs
Written by Sandy Williams
September 27, 2020
The Trump administration has received more than 3,300 lawsuits from manufacturers alleging that the most recent rounds of tariffs against China under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 were unlawful and arbitrary.
The first two rounds of tariffs covered $50 billion worth of Chinese goods. The third was implemented on $200 billion of imports and the fourth on $120 billion. The products in question include everything from household goods and clothing to machinery and auto parts. Plaintiffs allege that the United States Trade Representative exceeded its authority in imposing the third and fourth rounds and are seeking refunds for tariffs already paid.
A number of major automakers have filed lawsuits with the Court of International Trade including Tesla, Volvo, Ford and Mercedes Benz. Tesla called the tariffs “arbitrary, capricious, and an abuse of discretion.”
Mercedes Benz accused the administration of prosecuting “an unprecedented, unbounded, and unlimited trade war. Mercedes added that U.S. law “did not confer authority on defendants to litigate a vast trade war for however long, and by whatever means, they choose.”
The National Law Review states, “Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 authorizes the USTR to impose duties to combat certain ‘unreasonable’ or ‘discriminatory’ trade acts by a foreign government.” Tariffs are paid by the U.S. importers of those goods.
The National Review added, “The plaintiffs argue that the Section 301 law was not intended as a tool to engage in an ‘open-ended trade war,’as opposed to an initial response to China’s intellectual property violations.”
Although the lawsuits are consider a long shot at best, the sheer number of complaints are expected to garner serious attention from the CIT. Besides the automakers, major companies include HMTX Industries, Coca-Cola, Home Depot and Target.
“I would hope the court realizes that law firms and companies don’t sue the government on a whim. That while the payout could be significant, they would not do this without having looked at it carefully and done the due diligence to make sure the case is legitimate,” a lawyer told Inside U.S. Trade. “You don’t pull the trigger on suing the government lightly. I think the number of cases and the well-regarded law firms — that should have some impact on any judge’s views of the validity of the claims. I don’t think they can ignore that.”
Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Trade Cases
Price on Trade: The foolishness of free trade with controlled economies
It was only a matter of time before a shutdown happened. And, no, we aren’t talking about the federal government’s lapse in appropriations. On Oct. 9, Beijing announced a series of restrictions that will effectively shut down exports of rare earth elements, magnets, and certain downstream products vital to advanced manufacturing.
Trump pulls plug on trade talks with Canada after anti-tariff Reagan ad
US President Donald Trump took to social media late Thursday night to announce he was canceling trade talks with Canada.
Leibowitz: Renewed trade war with China over rare earths
On Oct.10, President Trump announced major increases in tariffs on Chinese goods. The trigger was a new regime of export controls on rare earth metals and products using those elements, including magnets, capital equipment, and catalysts for catalytic converters in cars and trucks.
Industry piles on new Section 232 steel derivative inclusion requests
The Department of Commerce received 97 submissions from producers, manufacturers, and groups seeking Section 232 tariff coverage for steel and aluminum derivative products.
Price on Trade: New EU steel tariffs don’t mean the US should weaken its stance
Any steel imports into the EU that exceed the new, lower quota level would be subject to a 50% tariff, which represents a major increase from the EU’s current 25% out-of-quota tariff. This move would largely align the EU’s steel tariff rate with Canada and the United States.