• Skip to main content

    Prices

    May 7, 2024

    HR futures: Nucor's price cut makes its mark on steel markets

    Written by Spencer Johnson

    When we were asked to provide some additional commentary to SMU about the futures markets for flat rolled, our only reluctance to contribute was rooted merely in the fact that SMU (1) already offers an excellent array of authors on this topic and (2) a concern regarding what new ground could be covered that hasn’t already been discussed to death on this issue.

    Thankfully, however, Nucor has offered up something we can describe, without hyperbole, as simply revolutionary for spot pricing in flat rolled – a development that we simply could not resist commenting on with respect to its probable impacts on the futures market.

    A mill price decrease?!

    In the past few weeks, markets have become extremely familiar with the introduction of the Nucor “CSP HRC base price” publication, which, like the CRU, is published weekly. But unlike CRU, it merely intends to offer the basis price for which Nucor’s producing mills will offer spot tons into the market. (The exception is California Steel Industries, which who is quoted at a separate premium.)

    It is important to keep the context of Nucor’s announcements clear. Nucor’s own price could never really work to supplant CRU as something like a futures market settlement mechanism. That’s because a calculation of spot prices needs to be based on a survey of all the separate producers and consumers in aggregate. It can’t be just one company whose own role might skew them from the overall average transacted price.

    So while there is a limit to the impact Nucor’s number will have, that does little to diminish the number’s significance in our eyes. This is not just because of Nucor’s size and general influence on the market. That is not to be underestimated. It is also because Nucor has demonstrated a direct willingness now in these past two weeks to let their number reflect the reality of a lower spot market. In addition, it gives us a data point ahead of the Wednesday CRU index that will help guide traders on a more frequent basis with what, so far, appears to be pretty accurate price updates.

    Now it would not seem quite so revolutionary for a steel market outsider to see this development. A price DECREASE announcement would be commonplace in any market where competitors seek to attract market share, right? Yes, but this is the steel market. And in our market we know full well that a price decrease announcement is unheard of.

    More data is a good thing

    This ties into one of the most frequent debates between financial players and physical hedgers in HRC, which is the infrequency of spot data. Even in other ferrous markets, like iron ore and scrap, we have a daily number. HRC, which of course settles off CRU, is weekly by nature. But this has often forced traders, for better or worse, to look for clues to the next CRU move through the lens of the other indices.

    Generally, trade and market price discovery work best when there is MORE data. Now, with two weekly numbers printing on different days of the week, and each carrying influence on their own, I think there is an immediate boost to the amount of activity we will expect to see.

    And so, Monday’s broad sell-off was without question tied directly to the Nucor announcement of a $760 per short ton (st) base, a more than $50/st discount to last week’s prevailing index price. It would again be without hyperbole to note that this announcement seemed to take most everyone a bit by surprise.

    Traders started pulling bids, and here we are now on June, trading as low as $766/ton. Note that June had already been pricing in a modest drop relative to current indices. Nucor may have just signaled, it would seem, that the drop is already here.

    What is priced in?

    And this brings us to our main point, which is to ask, “What is priced in”? Meaning what future developments in supply/demand are being priced into the forward price, and what interest rates, level of dollar strength, etc. These all play a role in determining how the forward market is priced.

    But ultimately, the question is broad. What is priced in? June has been trading at a discount to the spot index price now for months (trading in backwardation). Going into Monday, I don’t think “Nucor announces $50/ton price CUT” was being priced in. It is now based on Monday’s trading activity.

    With this in mind, we hope to bring our discussion of “What is priced in?” here to you the SMU readers a bit more regularly. I think you will find this is a different discussion entirely from “What is the price?” And perhaps one day, in an ideal world, we won’t be asking just “What is the price?” but also “What is priced in?” Because that latter question is, in my opinion, vastly more intriguing.

    Disclaimer

    This material should be construed as the solicitation of an account, order, and/or services provided by the FCM Division of StoneX Financial Inc. (“SFI”) (NFA ID: 0476094) or StoneX Markets LLC (“SXM”) (NFA ID: 0449652) and represents the opinions and viewpoints of the author. It does not constitute an individualized recommendation or take into account the particular trading objectives, financial situations, or needs of individual customers. Additionally, this material should not be construed as research material. The trading of derivatives such as futures, options, and over-the-counter (OTC) products or “swaps” may not be suitable for all investors. Derivatives trading involves substantial risk of loss, and you should fully understand the risks prior to trading. Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results. All references to and discussion of OTC products or swaps are made solely on behalf of SXM. All references to futures and options on futures trading are made solely on behalf of SFI. SXM products are intended to be traded only by individuals or firms who qualify under CFTC rules as an ‘Eligible Contract Participant’ (“ECP”) and who have been accepted as customers of SXM. SFI and SXM are not responsible for any redistribution of this material by third parties, or any trading decisions taken by persons not intended to view this material. Information contained herein was obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed as to its accuracy. Contact designated personnel from SFI or SXM for specific trading advice to meet your trading preferences. Reproduction or use in any format without authorization is forbidden. © Copyright 2024. All rights reserved.

    Spencer Johnson

    A broker at FCStone LLC, Johnson is a veteran in the world of steel futures. He has worked with every type of market participant to formulate risk management and trading strategies for steel derivatives. StoneX has also worked tirelessly to grow liquidity and provide access to new ferrous markets for its clients. Johnson is in addition one of the longest serving members of the London Metal Exchange’s steel committee.

    Read more from Spencer Johnson

    Latest in Prices

    Nucor temporarily halts secondary offers, sending shock waves through a tight market

    Nucor opened its secondary and excess product bid list across all its flat-rolled mills on Monday, as it typically does, market participants told SMU. But by Wednesday, when bidding was scheduled to close, Nucor notified buyers it would not be awarding any bids this week. The abrupt close sent a shock through the secondary market, they said. "Nucor pulled their excess and secondary lists this week and is not selling anything," a Midwest buyer said.

    Sheet prices surge as ’26 market squeeze spills into ’27

    Sheet prices soared this week as market participants increasingly predict that the strong market characterizing 2026 will stretch well into 2027. And with extremely limited spot availability, mills that have spot tons to sell are charging a significant premium, they said. The result: Sheet prices saw their highest week-over-week gains since March 2025, according to SMU's pricing records. That's when President Trump shocked the market by expanding Section 232 tariffs to cover traditional US allies such as Canada, Mexico, and the EU.

    Nucor increases spot HR to $1,280/ton

    Nucor said on Monday, Nov. 2, that its consumer spot price (CSP) for hot-rolled (HR) coil will be $1,280 per short ton (st) this week, up $10/st from last week. The CSP for HR coil from California Steel Industries (CSI) on the West Coast will be $1,350/st, also up $10/st from a week earlier. Nucor continues to offer lead times of three to five weeks, according to its letter to customers. You can track mill price announcements on our website. Steel Market Update published a weekly price assessment on Tuesday, Oct. 27, showing HR coil prices averaging $1,305/st, up $15/st from the previous week.

    HR Futures: Basic story remains, but curve shifts

    In my last column, the HRC futures curve was pricing a sizable premium on near-term tightness while still pointing toward eventual normalization. Since then, that basic story has remained intact, but the shape of the curve has shifted meaningfully. Rather than simply moving higher and pushing the peak out by another month, as has largely been the pattern throughout this rally, the curve is now pricing a more pronounced and prolonged period of tightness, while the long end has remained relatively anchored, which previously had also been lifted with the rest of the curve.

    galvalume steel coil

    SMU Survey: Mill willingness to negotiate price at lowest levels since 2021

    The majority of steel buyers responding to our latest market survey reported that mills continue to hold a firm grip on prices. The share of buyers reporting that mills were negotiable fell this week to the lowest rate seen in over five years. Every two weeks, SMU surveys service center and manufacturer buyers asking if mills are negotiable on new spot sheet and plate orders. In this week’s survey, just 3% of respondents said mills were willing to talk price to secure an order (Figure 1). This is down 11 percentage points from our mid-October survey.