• Skip to main content

    Prices

    HRC futures: A lot of change lurks beneath the surface

    Written by Daniel Doderer


    It has been six weeks since Flack Global Metals wrote our last SMU column, and if you simply look at the futures curve from then (blue) until now (white), you could argue that very little has changed. April and May are trading ~$50 higher than they were at that point, but the rest of the curve is essentially unchanged. However, for anyone who has been monitoring the futures and physical markets, this is obviously not the case. So, what actually happened?

    Going into the end of February, spot prices were falling sharply, following the collapse observed in futures prices throughout January. While spot prices caught up to the paper market, the curve was essentially stuck in the $800-850 range, eagerly waiting for the next shoe to drop. Then, right on time, buying on the forward curve began when rumors of significant physical market purchases and impending mill price hikes made the rounds. By the time the announcements did finally occur, futures were well on their way to a $200 rally. This rally culminated in the May contract settling at $979 on March 25 (orange, above) and an additional price announcement a few days later.

    Recently, we’ve observed a narrative unfolding in a strikingly familiar manner. The chart below shows the rolling 3rd month future going back to March of 2021.

    In 2022, we were coming off a shocking rally driven by raw material availability and cost concerns stemming from the fallout of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. From April to July, there was a significant and consistent selloff in the market, leading to a local bottom around $800. This occurred while the physical market was declining rapidly, yet still maintaining a price over $100 higher than the futures market. After the $110 rally in futures driven on the belief we had bottomed failed, the downward momentum resumed nine weeks later as the physical market weakened. This pushed futures below $800, ultimately bottoming below $650 in November.

    Then, in the summer of 2023, we saw something similar. After an impressive rally in Q1’23, the market was all sellers from March through May before we seemed to find a bottom for futures around $800 (when physical was more than $100 above the futures market and falling). Thinking a bottom was in place, this time, mill price hikes preceded a rally in the futures that nearly drove them $200 higher. However, these “stop-the-bleed” announcements failed to result in a meaningful physical market rally as demand did not match the financial expectations. Eight weeks later, we fell through $800 before ultimately bottoming at $718 in early September.

    What has occurred over the last two weeks since the futures market peaked certainly rhymes with what we’ve seen before. Futures reached steel’s psychological r* (for all the econ heads out there) at $800 in February. And the market appears to have been carried away in a “If it isn’t going down, it has to go up” type of mentality.

    Since peaking, we have seen steady and consistent selling in the futures market as the physical market appears to be in a stalemate between buyers and mills while reported transactions (albeit on lighter volume) continue to occur well below the latest announced price. From here, lead times remain depressed, mill cost support has fallen, and recent demand indicators have experienced downside surprises – all suggesting there is additional downside risk to futures and physical prices. At the same time, we are just now entering maintenance season with more than 300,000 tons of production coming offline, and a trade decision with Mexican tariffs will occur in less than two weeks. Both could have meaningful implications if demand starts to materialize more in line with market expectations. One thing that we know for certain, however, is that when we write our next column things will have certainly shaken loose.

    Daniel Doderer

    Read more from Daniel Doderer

    Latest in Prices

    SMU Price Ranges continue upward with spot tons still extremely scarce

    Sheet and plate prices continued to march higher on limited availability and no signs of a typical year-end slowdown. Prices have been rising since September 2025, the longest price rally in SMU’s data history – surpassing even the 2020-2021 rally. Buyers said they saw few signs of the rally stopping anytime soon amid late mill deliveries, scarce spot tons, limited contract tons, and strong demand. Availability continues to trump price, buyer sources said. To secure tons from mills, some sources continue to report buying from overseas – even as import lead times stretch into Q2. Others said they were concerned about taking positions that far out and so are buying from depot stocks held by traders – even if it means paying a significant premium.

    Nucor again raises spot HR coil by $15/ton

    Nucor said on Monday, Nov. 16, that its consumer spot price (CSP) for hot-rolled (HR) coil will be $1,310 per short ton (st) this week, up $15/st from last week. The CSP for HR coil from California Steel Industries (CSI) on the West Coast will be $1,380/st, also up $15/st from last week. Nucor continues to offer lead times of three to five weeks, according to a letter to customers. Nucor has held or increased its weekly hot band CSP since Aug. 25, 2025. The steelmaker's CSP is up $435/st over the 64-week run.

    Nucor aims to raise plate prices by $70/ton, opens December orderbook

    Nucor said on Friday morning it plans to increase plate prices by $70 per short ton (st) as it opens its December order book. The Charlotte, N.C.-based steelmaker said in a letter to customers that orders must be submitted by Nov. 27 to be considered. You can check out SMU’s Steel Mill Price Announcement Calendar to follow announced pricing moves. SMU’s price assessment for plate currently stands at $1,550/st on average, as of Tuesday, Nov. 10, up $55/st vs. the prior week.

    SMU’s ferrous scrap prices rise in November

    Ferrous scrap prices rose in November across all grades SMU tracks, though prices varied widely by region. “Marketwise, we saw disparate market movements between regions in the November trade, which wrapped up earlier this week,” one source told SMU. “It was a mixed bag, depending on the region and grade.” The source added that export pricing also rose over the course of last week, “but much less than the domestic market.”  Demand from US mills is strong and “there is probably more lift to be expected in the market between now and the January trade," he continued.

    SMU Survey: Steel mill negotiations remain rare as buyers face tight supply

    Only 5% of steel buyers surveyed by SMU this week said mills were willing to negotiate lower prices for new spot orders, suggesting mills retain substantial pricing leverage in a tight market. The share rose two percentage points from our previous survey two weeks ago but was nine points below the mid-October reading. This week's rate is just slightly higher than our previous survey when the negotiation rate fell to 3% — its lowest level since July 2021. Negotiation rates have trended downward all year as steel prices have continued to climb.