Final Thoughts

Final thoughts
Written by Michael Cowden
April 30, 2024
Hot rolled prices held roughly steady this week after slipping for much of April. I don’t have any spicy quotes to offer about mostly flat prices.
Besides, a lot of the questions I’ve gotten recently have been about demand. Some of you tell me that it’s still stable or improving. Others tell me that it’s suddenly dried up.
It’s hard to quantify anecdotal comments. So I went back through our steel market surveys to see if there was any evidence to support the notion that demand might be slowing down – or at least not overheating.
Demand is not bad (but not great either)
Here is where things stood over the last three months:

No big changes. Most people (60-70%) said they were meeting forecast. Around 7-10% said they were exceeding forecast. And about 20-30% said they were missing forecast.
Compare that to the late 2023 and early 2024:

That’s where we see some change. The number of folks missing forecast (~20-30%) hasn’t budged. But the number of people exceeding forecast was higher last year and through the start of this year (~15-20%).
Also, some of you who are meeting forecast tell me that you’ve adjusted forecasts a little lower. So, based on our survey data and comments like that, I think there might be something to the idea that demand has moderated.
There is also a range of outside data to support that notion. The Architectural Billings Index (ABI) fell to its lowest point since December 2020. The Chicago business barometer fell to its lowest point since November 2022. And service center’s sheet inventories are running a little high, especially with lead times stagnant.
Imports could remain high in April
Also, flat-rolled steel imports could remain elevated this month. The US was licensed to import 796,526 metric tons (mt) through April 23. That was the most recent data available when I filed this article on Tuesday evening.
That amounts to 34,632 mt per day. Or, theoretically, another 242,420 mt for the last week of the month. That gets us, in theory, to an April total of approximately 1.04 million mt.
That would be higher than the 950,426 mt of flat-rolled steel that arrived in March, according to preliminary government figures. And recall that the March figure was the highest since nearly 975,000 mt in August 2022.
I’m not saying it’s a slam dunk that April flat rolled will exceed 1 million mt. Import data can be lumpy. And there can be big gaps between license data and preliminary figures. Still, I’d also be surprised if April flat rolled imports turned out to be significantly lower than March.
And all else being equal, more supply and steady demand typically equates to lower prices. Or at least not sharply higher ones.
Normal is OK
That said, I’m not in the camp that’s singing the economic blues. Wages are rising. That might make life tricky for the Fed as it tries to tame inflation. Or for a stock market hoping for rate cuts.
But it’s not bad for consumers. One fun anecdote: When I was at the ISRI (ahem, ReMA) conference in Vegas earlier this month, the Strip was packed during the middle of the week. Not exactly a sign of an impending recession, that.
Here’s my best shot at squaring what I’ll call the doom-and-gloom camp and the steady-Eddie camp. Demand is stable. Maybe down a tick. And after several years of record prices and profits, normal might not feel so great. But that doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with it.
What do you think? Let us know at info@steelmarketupdate.com.
SMU Steel Summit
Our hotel blocks for this year’s Steel Summit – Aug. 26-28 at the Georgia International Convention Center (GICC) in Atlanta – are going fast. Don’t miss your chance to get discounted hotel rates on the GICC campus, register now!

Michael Cowden
Read more from Michael CowdenLatest in Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
An exciting first look at the results from SMU's first scrap survey.

Final Thoughts
As Wolfe Research’s Timna Tanner put it in her opening talk at Tampa on Monday afternoon, we’re living in a world of “Trumplications” now. That probably means – at least in the short term – higher scrap costs, lower imports from countries hit with or threated tariffs, and higher steel prices. SMU data reflects that. Scrap went up in January. More than 75% of the respondents to our more recent survey expect scrap to go up again February, maybe by a lot. Lead times, meanwhile, have been ticking upward this month. It started with hot-rolled coil and plate earlier this month. Now we’re seeing coated lead times extending too.

Final Thoughts
We joked in our last Final Thoughts that Wiley trade attorney Tim Brightbill – one of the nation’s leading experts on trade law and policy – would probably be revising his presentation on Trump, trade policy, and tariffs for the Tampa Steel Conference. He did. And even after those last-minute revisions, he actually got trumped […]

Final Thoughts
The whole SMU team is packing up our laptops and our SMU polos/cardigans, loading up the PowerPoint slides, and preparing to make the trek down to Florida for the Tampa Steel Conference. There will be plenty to talk about!

Final Thoughts
From one group of folks, I’ve heard that Trump might not wait until Feb. 1 – the date he threatened on to place tariffs on China, Canada, and Mexico. They say he could act as soon as Friday. And then there are those who don’t think anything will happen before April 1. That’s the deadline for Commerce, Treasury, and USTR to submit key reports on “America First Trade Policy” to President Trump.