Features

SMA, MSCI: USMCA vital to North America as long as rules followed
Written by Ethan Bernard
June 11, 2024
The USMCA is an important trade agreement, as long as the member countries honor its requirements. These were the sentiments echoed by top officials of the Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA) and the Metals Service Center Institute (MSCI) during a press conference at their annual meeting last week in Scottsdale, Ariz.
“We think the USMCA is a landmark piece of legislation. I think it serves as a template for how other free trade agreements can work,” said Philip K. Bell, president of SMA.
“And I am extremely hopeful that all the parties that are involved in USMCA—Canada, Mexico and the US—continue to live up to the spirit of it and continue to do what they can to serve as a united front against transshipment, unfairly traded imports, and global excess steel capacity,” he added.
Recall that the US-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) trade agreement of 2019 removed Section 232 tariffs from Canada and Mexico.
MSCI operates across borders
MSCI President and CEO Bob Weidner noted that MSCI members include service centers in both the US and Canada.
“So, we’ve been very supportive of pro-North American—Canada, US, and Mexican—trade policies,” Weidner said. “And the connectivity that exists. We have members moving product back and forth across the borders.”
Still, he said he’s concerned with non-market economies that could be circumventing and breaking trade rules by bringing products in through Canada or through Mexico.
MSCI Chairman John G. Reid echoed this with his unique point of view. He is also director, president, and CEO of Mississauga, Ontario-based metals distributor Russel Metals, which itself operates on both sides of the Canada-US border.
He said the agreement is definitely a benefit to its North American members, as long as everyone follows the rules.
“A strong North American economy governed under these rules really benefits everyone in manufacturing,” Reid said.
Likewise, Weidner underlined that a “healthy domestic source of supply” is needed, referring to all of North America, “but equally as important is a healthy domestic source of demand, because without demand there are no orders.”
Actions to be taken
Bell pointed out that for Mexico to live up to the spirit of the USMCA, two things must be true: “You cannot be a haven for transshipment. And also, you yourself cannot be engaging in import surges of certain products.”
Tensions have escalated as US industry and politicians have lamented a “surge” of steel imports from Mexico.
The “Stop Mexico’s Steel Surge Act,” introduced into both Houses of Congress in March, seeks to reimpose Section 232 tariffs. However, Mexico has threatened to retaliate if such measures go through.
Bell stressed that the USMCA region needs a melt-and-pour standard, “that is steel that’s traded between these three countries … needs to be melted and poured in the region.”
Bell also said there needs to be more transparency and strengthening of the import monitoring systems with Mexico to address allegations of transshipment.
“And we’ve been negotiating this for a long time,” Bell added. “I think we’re making steady progress, but we need to make more, and we need to make it faster.”

Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Features

Final Thoughts
If I could change something, it’d be this: Political news would get more boring. And news about steel prices and steel demand would get a little more exciting.

US and Canada expect positive outcomes from tariff negotiations
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump told reporters at the White House on Tuesday that they’ll be formulating a trade deal that works for both nations.

Final Thoughts: Survey says edition
SMU’s latest survey results indicate that steel market participants think sheet prices are at or near a bottom. But most also think there is limited upside once they inflect higher.

SMU Scrap Survey: Current and Future Sentiment tick down
SMU’s Current Sentiment Index for scrap decreased this month, a move mirrored by our Future Sentiment Index, according to the latest data from our ferrous scrap survey.

Leibowitz: When the shutdown should end
There is no doubt that the current government shutdown reflects the vast divisions between the extremes of American politics, society, and even geography. Almost all Americans agree that government is necessary, but voters disagree...